Cultural humility in libraries

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to introduce the idea of cultural humility, distinguish it from cultural competence and explore how it fits within librarianship. Design/methodology/approach The authors use an interdisciplinary exploration of the concept of humility to understand what cultural humility means and how it differs from cultural competence and other approaches to intercultural communication in libraries. Findings Despite some reservations with the term itself, the authors find that a practice of cultural humility is more appropriate to front-line interactions in library contexts than cultural competence models. Practical implications Libraries looking to address issues in intercultural communication and services to multicultural populations will find an approach that may be better suited to their contexts than prevailing models of cultural competency. Social implications Librarians need to commit to redressing the power imbalances and other structural issues that interfere with library service, for the benefit of the patrons, the library and librarians themselves. Originality/value While cultural humility is increasingly being used in librarianship, there has not been a systematic exploration of the concept and how it applies to library contexts.

“You can't read your way out of racism”: creating anti-racist action out of education in an academic library

“…We know that the work of equity, inclusion, and anti-racism is continuous; it is, as the clich e goes, a marathon not a sprint. As the IDEA Council presses forward in facilitating conversation and encouraging direct action, we do so with humility and with recognition of the identities we bring to this work (Hurley et al, 2019). We do this work collectively because we know as BIPOC and white colleagues, our solidarity and liberation are bound together.…”

Putting DEIA into practice: incorporating diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility into student employee training

“…Librarians are working on their own to develop training or partnering with campus groups who do this work (Andrade and Rivera, 2011; Berray, 2019). Others are noting what cultural competence could bring to libraries and library workers (Hurley et al. , 2019).…”

“…Librarians are working on their own to develop training or partnering with campus groups who do this work (Andrade and Rivera, 2011;Berray, 2019). Others are noting what cultural competence could bring to libraries and library workers (Hurley et al, 2019). Notably Brook et al (2015) argue that "[o]nly through trainings in cultural competence that emphasize power differentials and microaggressions, as well as the application of critical pedagogical methods in reference interactions, will library workers begin to build transformative antiracist solidarities based on authentic mutual care and aid" (p. 278).…”

Developing Cultural Humility in Leadership Education Programs to Promote Community Leadership

“…171–172). This self‐reflection may sway both educators and students from using their own views, values, and beliefs as the standard, and instead, realize and accept that “my norms aren't the only norms” (Hurley et al, 2019, p. 549). This awareness can dampen the view that “one's own values and culture are superior” (Van Tongeren et al, 2019, p. 464).…”