Cultural aspects of primary healthcare in india: A case- based analysis

Abstract

Delivering quality primary care to large populations is always challenging, and that is certainly the case in India. While the sheer magnitude of patients can create difficulties, not all challenges are about logistics. Sometimes patient health-seeking behaviour leads to delays in obtaining medical help for reasons that have more to do with culture, social practice and religious belief. When primary care is accessed via busy state-run outpatient departments there is often little time for the physician to investigate causes behind a patient's condition, and these factors can adversely affect patient outcomes. We consider the case of a woman with somatic symptoms seemingly triggered by psychological stresses associated with social norms and familial cultural expectations. These expectations conflict with her personal and professional aspirations, and although she eventually receives psychiatric help and her problems are addressed, initially, psycho-social factors underlying her condition posed a hurdle in terms of accessing appropriate medical care. While for many people culture, belief and social norms exert a stabilising, positive influence, in situations where someone's personal expectations differ significantly from accepted social norms, individual autonomy can be directly challenged, and in which case, something has to give. The result of such challenges can negatively impact on health and well-being, and for patients with immature defence mechanisms for dealing with inner conflict, such an experience can be damaging and ensuing somatic disturbances are often difficult to treat. Patients with culture-bound symptoms are not uncommon within primary care in India or in other Asian countries and communities. We argue that such cases need to be properly understood if satisfactory patient outcomes are to be achieved. While some causes are structural, having to do with how healthcare is accessed and delivered, others are about cultural values, social practices and beliefs. We note how some young adult women are adversely affected and discuss some of the ethical issues that arise.

‘That is how the real mad people behave’: Beliefs about and treatment of mental disorders by traditional medicine-men in Accra, Ghana

“…These beliefs fit into what has been described as a distinctly African notion of illness (Anderson, 2004), which includes the belief in illness or misfortune being a consequence of a person’s behaviour or punishment. These views may also be common in other non-western contexts (Marsella & White, 1982; Worthington & Gogne, 2011).…”

Implementation of a community-based intervention in the most rural and remote districts of Zambia: a process evaluation of safe motherhood action groups

“…In these remote areas, women found it easier to disclose pregnancy-related issues to female SMAGs than male SMAGs, as healthcare occurs within cultural-bound norms and sensitive socio-cultural factors, often more common in remote rural communities [ 43 , 44 ]. The findings thus suggest a need for gendered SMAG roles [ 45 ] and male-female task sharing functions if MNH services are to be optimised for marginalised women in remote and hard-to-reach areas.…”

Access to Services and Barriers faced by People with Disabilities: A Quantitative Survey

“…Interestingly, the only barriers with no statistically significant difference between people with and without disabilities were family assistance and family attitudes. This is interesting in the south Asian context where, in the absence of significant government support, the family network often plays an important role in care (Worthington and Gogne, 2011;Kumar et al, 2012). In India, the family plays an important role in increasing access to services, healthcare, work and education.…”