Asymmetric catalytic reactions rely on chiral catalysts that induce highly ordered transition states capable of imparting stereoselectivity in the bond-forming step(s). Productive deviations from this paradigm are rare yet hold the potential for accessing different stereoisomers using the same catalyst. Here, we present an enantio-and diastereoselective Michael addition of βketo amides to nitroolefin electrophiles proceeding via an unusual scenario where the kinetic diastereocontrol imparted by the catalyst may be overridden by crystallization to provide the complementary stereoisomer of the product.