Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I participates in DNA replication, DNA repair, and genetic recombination; it is the most extensively studied of all DNA polymerases. Motif A in the polymerase active site has a required role in catalysis and is highly conserved. To assess the tolerance of motif A for amino acid substitutions, we determined the mutability of the 13 constituent amino acids Val 700 -Arg 712 by using random mutagenesis and genetic selection. We observed that every residue except the catalytically essential Asp 705 can be mutated while allowing bacterial growth and preserving wild-type DNA polymerase activity. Hence, the primary structure of motif A is plastic. We present evidence that mutability of motif A has been conserved during evolution, supporting the premise that the tolerance for mutation is adaptive. In addition, our work allows identification of refinements in catalytic function that may contribute to preservation of the wildtype motif A sequence. As an example, we established that the naturally occurring Ile 709 has a previously undocumented role in supporting sugar discrimination.Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (pol I) 1 is a multifunctional enzyme with roles in DNA replication, DNA repair, and genetic recombination (1). The first recognized and most thoroughly investigated of all DNA polymerases, it is key to our understanding of how DNA polymerases function as protein catalysts and as central enzymes in DNA metabolism. It belongs to one of six families of DNA polymerases, defined on the basis of amino acid sequence comparisons (2-4): family A (e.g. E. coli pol I, Thermus aquaticus (Taq) pol I, Bacillus stearothermophilus pol I, and T7 DNA polymerase), family B (e.g. DNA polymerase ␣ and RB69 DNA polymerase), reverse transcriptase (e.g. human immunodeficiency virus reverse transcriptase, and murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase), family X (e.g. DNA polymerase ), the pol III family, and the UmuC/DinB family (e.g. DNA polymerase ). Crystal structures of representative enzymes from the first four families have been determined, revealing a common overall architecture that has been likened to a human right hand, with fingers, thumb, and palm subdomains (5-9). Although the structures of the fingers and thumb subdomains vary considerably, the catalytic palm subdomains are all superimposable (10, 11). The palm subdomain includes two conserved sequences, motif A and motif C, each harboring a catalytically essential aspartic acid residue. Essential roles of motif A in catalysis include interaction with the incoming dNTP and coordination with two divalent metal ions that are required for the polymerization reaction (12-15). Motif A begins at an anti-parallel -strand containing predominantly hydrophobic residues and is followed by a turn and an ␣-helix. Although there is considerable variation in the amino acid sequence of the anti-parallel -strand, the sequence of the turn and helix, DYSQIELR, is nearly invariant among known prokaryotic family A polymerases (16).
2In a recent study of Ta...