“…The fi rst group has been the most extensively explored, with solvents or catalysts (other than transition metal melts) such as kimberlitic melts (Arima et al 1993), solid or liquid carbonate (Akaishi et al 1990;Taniguchi et al 1996;Pal'yanov et al 1999aPal'yanov et al , 1999bPal'yanov et al , 2002aSato et al 1999;Sokol et al 2000Sokol et al , 2001aSpivak and Litvin 2004;Tomlinson et al 2004), sulfi de melts (Pal'yanov et al 2001;Sato and Katsura 2001), and both oxidized (CO 2 -H 2 O) and reduced (CH 4 -H 2 O) fl uids (Yamaoka et al 1992(Yamaoka et al , 2002a(Yamaoka et al , 2002bKumar et al 2000Kumar et al , 2001Sun et al 2000;Akaishi et al , 2001Sokol et al 2001b;Okada et al 2002;Dobrzhinetskaya et al 2004). To the authors' knowledge, no study has reported oxidation of a reduced, carbon-bearing (e.g., CH 4 -rich) fl uid to produce diamond in the absence of graphite or another source of carbon.…”