Cross-Validation of the MEDEAS Energy-Economy-Environment Model with the Integrated MARKAL-EFOM System (TIMES) and the Long-Range Energy Alternatives Planning System (LEAP)

Abstract

In the present study, we compare energy transition scenarios from a new set of integrated assessment models, the suite of MEDEAS models, based on a systems dynamic modeling approach, with scenarios from two already well know structurally and conceptually different integrated assessment models, the Integrated MARKAL-EFOM System (TIMES) and the Long-Range Energy Alternatives Planning system (LEAP). The investigation was carried out to cross-compare and benchmark the response of MEDEAS models with TIMES and LEAP in depicting the energy transition in two different countries, Austria and Bulgaria. The preliminary results show a good agreement across all the models in representing scenarios projecting historical trends, while a major discrepancy is detectable when the rate of implementation of renewable energy is forced to increase to achieve energy system decarbonization. The discrepancy is mainly traceable to the differences in the models’ conception and structures rather than in a real mismatch in representing the same scenarios. The present study is put forward as a guideline for validating new modeling approaches that link energy policy decision tools to the global biophysical and socioeconomic constraints.

Impact of Large-Scale Electric Vehicles’ Promotion in Thailand Considering Energy Mix, Peak Load, and Greenhouse Gas Emissions

“…It is a scenario-focused energy system modeling software from the Stockholm Environment Institute [43]. LEAP, as an optimization framework, finds widespread application in diverse fields including integrated energy modeling, water resource management, emission estimation, and generation expansion planning [44][45][46][47][48]. LEAP employs the accounting method for energy-related activities simulation.…”

Bioresource Value Model: Case of Crop Production

“…Lastly, the Integrated MARKAL-EFOM System (TIMES) model [41] is bottom-up, linear programming tool applied for long-term energy systems planning allowing to analyse effect of different scenarios. It optimises the whole energy system including supply and demand services by minimizing the total cost in the considered modelling period [42].…”

Forestry Sector Resource Optimization with TIMES

“…The TIMES model is used to identify a solution for energy supply with the least amount of total energy loss and energy production at the lowest cost [57]- [60], while having the ability to take into consideration the added value of the products from biorefineries. Henceforth, the modelling approach is selected for purpose of this study, and the model created is named as Forestry Bioresource Value Model (FBVM).…”