Cross-cultural perspectives on the patient-provider relationship: a qualitative study exploring reflections from Ghanaian medical students following a clinical rotation in the United States

Abstract

BackgroundIn international health experiences, learners are exposed to different culturally-based patient care models. Little is known about student perceptions of patient-provider interactions when they travel from low-to high-resource settings. The purpose of this study was to explore these reflections among a subset of Ghanaian medical students who participated in clinical rotations at the University of Michigan Medical School (UMMS).MethodsIn-depth, semi-structured interviews lasting 60–90 min were conducted with 15 individuals who had participated in 3-to 4-week clinical rotations at UMMS between January 2008 and December 2011. Interviews were conducted from March to August 2012 and transcribed verbatim, then independently coded by three investigators. Investigators compared open codes and reached a consensus regarding major themes.ResultsParticipating Ghanaian medical students reported that their perspectives of the patient-provider relationship were significantly affected by participation in a UMMS rotation. Major thematic areas included: (1) observations of patient care during the UMMS rotation, including patient comfort and privacy, physician behavior toward patients, and patient behavior; (2) reflections on the role of humanism and respect within patient care; (3) barriers to respectful care; and (4) transformation of student behaviors and attitudes. Students also reported integrating more patient-centered care into their own medical practice upon return to GhanaDiscussionParticipation in a US-based clinical rotation has the potential to introduce medical students from resource-limited settings to a different paradigm of patient-provider interactions, which may impact their future behavior and perspectives regarding patient care in their home countries.ConclusionsStudents from under-resourced settings can derive tremendous value from participation in clinical electives in more affluent settings, namely through exposure to a different type of medical care.

Embedding international medical student electives within a 30-year partnership: the Ghana-Michigan collaboration

“…Few studies have explored the impact of participation in international medical electives embedded within long-standing, sustainable partnerships. Beginning with the co-creation of an in-country postgraduate training program for Ghanaian obstetrician gynecologists (OBGYNs) in 1989, the University of Michigan Medical School (UMMS) has had longstanding relationships with a growing number of partner institutions in Ghana [8][9][10], where it has been intentional about developing an ethically informed bidirectional partnership between the University and collaborative Ghanaian medical schools [11,12]. In addition to the 246 OBGYN residents trained to date, a hallmark of the partnership has been a robust bilateral exchange of learners and faculty from multiple medical specialties.…”

Social markers of a pandemic: modeling the association between cultural norms and COVID-19 spread data

“…influencing citizens' choice through persuasion and not by using of force or compulsion) as well, and there can be considerable cross-cultural differences in the population's tolerance for a certain level of paternalism, i.e. in countries where shared-decision making or egalitarian approaches are adopted, strict paternalism may be more easily rejected, while in other regions of the world with different cultural standards, people might be more accepting towards a more paternalistic leadership (Abedini et al, 2015). Currently one of the most important question that still remains unanswered is whether or not libertarian paternalism (e.g.…”

Current Practices in Hosting Non-US Pharmacy Students at US Pharmacy Schools in Experiential Clerkships

“…Topics to cover may include not only issues related to the local area, language, and differences in the general U.S. health care system, but also regarding caring for patients in the U.S. 21 Visiting students should be aware of the diversity of patients in the U.S. from a variety of factors, such as diversity of racial/ethnic groups and religions. Understanding that there may be great variability in common clinical conditions of varying racial/ethnic groups seen in the U.S., as well as how U.S. patients view health care, may impact the visiting students' understanding of the delivery of care practiced or witnessed on their visit to the U.S. 22,23 Institutions hosting international students should also be mindful of the cultural adjustment phase of the visiting students. The "U Curve of Cultural Adjustment" is frequently cited when describing the adjustment of visitors to a new country.…”