Croatia: Omnipotent Judges as the Cause of Procedural Inefficiency and Impotence

Uzelac, Alan

doi:10.1007/978-94-007-7666-1_10

Cited by 3 publications

(2 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Maulina Sari ADHKI: Journal of Islamic Family Law For judges, the principle of ultra petitum partium with ex officio rights has a very close relationship in order to realize a fair decision. Therefore it can be selected appropriately and proportionally (Uzelac, 2013). The ex officio rights of judges are a concrete step to break through the prohibition of the ultra petitum partium principle which becomes a barrier for judges in examining cases to provide justice and legal protection to all litigants in order to realize justice based on the Almighty God (Mukti, 2017).…”

Section: Analysis Of Judges' Reasons Regarding the Application Of The...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Effectiveness of Ultra Petitum Partium in Divorce Claims in Religious Courts

Nurhidayati,

Liberty,

Nugraha

et al. 2023

ADHKI

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The ultra petitum partiumis a principle that doesn’t allow judge to make verdicts on unrequested or over-demanding cases. In divorcement cases, ithas limited the authority of the judge in giving verdicts to grant women's rights. The existence of a Supreme Court Circular Letter (SEMA) on number 3 of 2018 strengthened by PERMA on number 3 of 2017 concerning The Guidelines for Prosecuting Women Facing the Law opens a gap for judges to consider this principle. The type of this research is empirical legal research. The data obtained through field research and qualitative descriptive. The primary data sources in this study were collected through observations, and judges interview in the Metro Religious Courts. The secondary data sources are acquired from library (legislation and certain related books). The data analysis method conducted in 3 stages, 1. Collecting the data, 2.Restating the statement, and 3. Connecting the datawith existed theories. The results shows that the Metro Religious Court Judges still override the existence of a Supreme Court Circular (SEMA) number 3 of 2018 because it is only limited to the formulation of rooms that are not binding as legislations. It is may also be applied or ignored.

show abstract

Section: Analysis Of Judges' Reasons Regarding the Application Of The...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Effectiveness of Ultra Petitum Partium in Divorce Claims in Religious Courts

Nurhidayati,

Liberty,

Nugraha

et al. 2023

ADHKI

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…I ranije je postojala svijest da je to samo dio problema, s obzirom na to da brojni suci jednostavno ne primjenjuju ostale procesne mogućnosti koje su alternativa korištenju poštanskih usluga. 42 Dostava je bila predmetom brojnih novela ZPP-a, no fakultativnost različitih metoda o kojima odlučuje sud u kombinaciji s nomotehničkom složenošću novih odredbi, nisu dali odgovarajuće rezultate. 43 To je potvrdilo i ranije istraživanje autora, prema kojem je u gotovo polovici predmeta u uzorku došlo do nekog oblika problema s dostavom, a oni su bili razlogom odgode više od trećine pripremnih i desetine ročišta za glavnu raspravu.…”

Section: Odabir Najučinkovitije Metode Dostaveunclassified

Učinkovito provođenje prethodnog postupka

Brozović

2022

Zb. Prav. fak. Sveuč. Rij. (Online)

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Prethodni postupak u hrvatskom postupku postoji više od desetljeća, noistraživanja su pokazala da još uvijek nije ostvario svoju temeljnu funkcijuubrzanja i koncentracije parničnog postupka. To se djelomično može objasnitipostupnim i donekle ležernim pristupom reformama koje nisu uvijek učinjenedosljedno i nomotehnički precizno, ali i nepravilnim shvaćanjem smisla togaposebnog stadija u sudskoj praksi, odnosno smisla pojedinih zadaća čije sepoduzimanje u sklopu njega očekuje. Svrha je ovog rada primjenom modernihshvaćanja o parničnom postupku (re)interpretirati zakonske odredbe oprethodnom postupku, na temelju rezultata empirijskih istraživanja i dostupnesudske prakse analizirati njihovo shvaćanje i primjenu u sudskoj praksiviših sudova te dati preporuke kako provođenje prethodnog postupka učinitiučinkovitijim u svakom od njegovih podstadija. U nekim dijelovima rada autorse kritički odmiče od postojeće prakse i upozorava na značenje najavljenihizmjena i dopuna Zakona o parničnom postupku iz 2022.

show abstract

In Search of Efficiency: Court Structure and Case Management in Croatia

Bratković

2021

Civil Case Management in the Twenty-First Century: Court Structures Still Matter

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Croatia: Omnipotent Judges as the Cause of Procedural Inefficiency and Impotence

Cited by 3 publications

References 0 publications

Effectiveness of Ultra Petitum Partium in Divorce Claims in Religious Courts

Effectiveness of Ultra Petitum Partium in Divorce Claims in Religious Courts

Učinkovito provođenje prethodnog postupka

In Search of Efficiency: Court Structure and Case Management in Croatia

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About