Critical Thinking in Ethical and Neutral Settings in Gifted Children and Non-Gifted Children

Abstract

The present study examined the performance on five phases of critical thinking in gifted and nongifted children in two settings: ethical and neutral. Ninety-one children, 32 gifted (8–10 years old), 32 normally developing children matched for chronological age (8–10 years old) and 27 normally developing children matched for mental age (12–13 years old) completed critical thinking tasks. The findings confirmed that intellectually gifted children had higher critical thinking capacity than typically developing children. The results reveal that the basic factor determining best performances in critical thinking is mental age and not chronological age. However, critical thinking ability was the same in ethical and neutral settings. Analysis of the phases of critical thinking show that the first and the third phase, clarification and evaluation, specifically differentiates gifted from nongifted children. These phases refer to the ability to understand the type of problem rapidly and to assess the credibility of statements and to assess the logical strength of the actual or intended inferential relationships among statements, descriptions, questions or other forms of representation.

The Influence of Smartphone Use on Tweens’ Capacity for Complex Critical Thinking

“…The current paper yields two key findings: (1) individuals who use smartphones less problematically exhibit greater levels of reflection compared to those who use smartphones more frequently; (2) critical thinking about social issues appears to be easier than critical thinking about mathematical problems. Considering the importance of critical thinking as a valuable cognitive process in problem solving [ 68 , 69 , 70 ], educational institutions should implement targeted strategies to foster the development of this skill. Developing critical thinking abilities can help individuals overcome biases and thinking errors, leading to a more objective understanding of reality.…”

Science Teaching Materials Based on Field Trips with Local Wisdom to Improve Elementary School Students' Critical Thinking

“…The low critical thinking ability can be seen through learning based only on memorization ability (Almadiah et al, 2022). The primary factor in determining the best performance results in critical thinking is mentality, not age (Fabio et al, 2023;Saldıray & Meydan, 2023). Critical thinking skills can be cultivated from an early age (Changwong et al, 2018;Shao et al, 2022).…”