Critical Reflexivity of Communities on Their Experience to Improve Population Health

Abstract

Although community capacity has been prominent in the public health literature for nearly 20 years, the field has only operationalized a few dimensions. An intriguing dimension of capacity is a community's ability to critically reflect. On the basis of previous research as well as theoretical and practical insights from management and organizational learning literature, we offer a process framework for critical reflexivity practice in community. The framework draws on ideas regarding cognition and agency, praxis, as well as the transformative learning model to conceptualize how reflexivity happens as an emergent community process. The implication is that reflexivity is a community-level process of making meaning of experiences that drive a common narrative. Inclusivity and establishing consensus are paramount, and can be difficult in light of power dynamics and consideration of dissenting voices and different experiences; enlightened self-interest and creating conducive spaces for dialogue are key in this process. Strengthening communities' ability to gain and employ collective wisdom from their experience will also build their overall capacity for population health improvement.

The Dual-Challenge of Teaching Online in a Foreign Land: Understanding Western Foreign Teachers’ Professional Identity and Confidence Development via a Transformative Learning Lens

“…In reflective conversations, individuals explore uncertain parts of the situation and gradually gain insights as they make sense of the lived experience (Anand et al, 2020a ). As people contemplate the unfamiliar aspects of their experiences, they identify potential actions to cope with challenges (Wendel et al, 2018 ), which helps them become more skilled at problem-solving. A series of reflective practices lead to the alignment of actions that can further refine people’s mental habits and points of view (Mezirow, 1996 , 1997b , 2003 ).…”

The Beneficiary Voice in Impact Measurement for Social Entrepreneurship

“…Various disciplines, such as social work, psychology and organizational behaviour have advanced thinking around critical reflexivity. At the individual level, the practice of reflexivity is one of intentional introspection in order to improve a behaviour to achieve a desired outcome (Wendel et al, 2018). At the institutional level, reflexivity is a social process that is practiced collectively, but with the same goal of organizational introspection in order to achieve an outcome.…”

Social Justice, Triage, and COVID-19

“…We can reasonably begin with a foundational moral framework open to reflexive elaboration and revisions. 6 Task force composition, function, and ultimate triage policies should fit core ethical features such as principles and values.…”