‘Crisis’ and ‘everyday’ initiators: A qualitative study of coercion and agency in the context of methadone maintenance treatment initiation

Abstract

Introduction and Aims Patient attrition is common among people enrolled in methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) programs and most pronounced during the first year of treatment. However, the experiences of patients initiating MMT have been overlooked in the literature. This study explores experiences of MMT initiation among MMT patients, focusing on contextual influences on MMT initiation and perceptions of MMT and their subsequent influence on treatment retention. Design and Methods Semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with 39 MMT patients in Vancouver, Canada. Individuals reporting enrolment in MMT were recruited from within two ongoing cohort studies comprised of people who use drugs. Interview transcripts were analysed using an inductive and iterative approach. Results Two groups of MMT initiators were identified: (i) ‘crisis initiators’ prescribed methadone following critical transition events, such as incarceration or pregnancy; and (ii) ‘everyday initiators’ enrolled in MMT as part of routine healthcare utilisation. While most ‘crisis initiators’ and some ‘everyday initiators’ described experiencing coercion during MMT initiation, ‘crisis initiators’ were further subjected to the coercive leveraging of their vulnerability to motivate ‘consent’ for MMT. ‘Crisis initiators’ developed negative views towards MMT and were more likely to discontinue treatment. Long-standing patient– provider relationships and open dialogue were associated with more positive views regarding MMT, regardless of the circumstances of initiation. Discussion and Conclusion Findings underscore the need for clear and effective communication regarding treatment regimens and expectations during MMT initiation. Furthermore, training in trauma-informed care may help reduce perceptions of coercion and rates of early treatment termination.

Understanding concurrent stimulant use among people on methadone: A qualitative study

“…In brief, cohort participants are recruited through community outreach and a research office. They complete structured questionnaires and clinical assessments at baseline and every 6 months thereafter [17].…”

“…Qualitative research among structurally vulnerable polysubstance‐using individuals from a variety of settings, including Vancouver, Canada, supports the notion that the acceptance of and adherence to methadone treatment is a much more complex situation than is reflected in clinical and epidemiological studies . These studies have suggested that treatment goals of people who use drugs might not necessarily be abstinence from all substance use .…”

Naloxone for heroin, prescription opioid, and illicitly made fentanyl overdoses: Challenges and innovations responding to a dynamic epidemic

“…Emergency department post-overdose care can be an overwhelming and potentially traumatic experience for users (Damon et al, 2016), as well as a potentially inefficient use of limited resources. An innovative example of post-overdose care is Vancouver's Mobile Medical Unit (MMU) (Woo, 2017).…”

Coercion into addiction treatment and subsequent substance use patterns among people who use illicit drugs in Vancouver, Canada

“…Informal perceived pressures to engage in treatment have also received attention [5,6,[16][17][18][19][20], with some literature suggesting that informal perceived coercion improves substance use outcomes [6,16,18]. This is most notably observed in work environments where licensing bodies pressure employees to engage in treatment to maintain their accreditation (e.g.…”