Criminality, thinking patterns and treatment effects – evaluation of the Swedish cognitive intervention programme ‘new challenges’ targeting adult men with a criminal lifestyle

Abstract

The cognitive intervention programme 'New Challenges' targeting adult men with a criminal lifestyle was evaluated in a pilot study. The participants were divided into a cognitive treatment group (n = 32) and a control group (n = 11). In the control group, six participants had no treatment and five participated in 12-step treatment. The participants were measured pre and post using the Psychological Inventory of Criminal Thinking Styles (PICTS), the abridged version of sense of coherence (SOC), Positive and Negative Affect Scale, and Bergström's quality of programme delivery (QPD). The results of the treatment group showed that criminal thinking patterns dropped significantly from high values to close to normal level. SOC and positive affect increased significantly in the treatment group. Both SOC and positive affect showed positive correlation with QPD. Regarding the possible influence of the 12-step treatment, there was no difference in the control group between participants receiving 12-step treatment and those not receiving treatment. The main conclusion is that the cognitive treatment programme 'New Challenges' can contribute to reduced criminal thinking and increased SOC and positive affect, which may prove to be important precursors of reduced criminality.

Psychological Resilience Interventions to Reduce Recidivism in Young People: A Systematic Review

“…A recent systematic review found that youth who were depressed or anxious, misused drugs and alcohol, had poor social skills or conduct problems, or engaged in delinquent behavior were also more likely to have low sense of coherence (Lansimies et al 2017). Despite SOC developing during adolescence, studies have reported that SOC (and reductions in re-offending) can increase following intervention with adult men (Lindblom et al 2018). Furthermore, in a study of incarcerated women, increased SOC related to a significant decrease in global emotional distress (Höjdahl et al 2015).…”

“A Silver Duck in the Dish Washing Water” or Love and Crime in the Context of Positive Victimology

“…Research has shown that the 12-step-programme, originally introduced by Bill Wilson, a co-founder of Alcoholics Anonymous, impacts positively on sense of coherence and positive affect, and reduces criminal thinking (Lindblom, Eriksson, & Hiltunen, 2017). The belief in a higher power and meaning in life can contribute to coping with difficult life situations, suffering and the experience of crime and violence (Chen, 2010).…”

Fagin’s Criminal Thought in Charles Dickens’ Oliver Twist

“…In other words, criminal thought is an idiosyncratic way of thinking that "develops to support, buttress, and reinforce one's criminal decisions" (Walters, 1990:p.83). Nevertheless, Fridell and Hesse (in Lindblom et al, 2018) emphasized that trends, norms, and consequences of criminal behavior are often overlooked, as it has been shown that these factors predict relapsing crime. Thus, it is important to discuss criminal thought.…”