Criminal History and Assault of Dating Partners: The Role of Type of Prior Crime, Age of Onset, and Gender

Abstract

Some studies of assaults on intimate partners have found that most of the perpetrators are not violent outside the family, which suggests a specialized type of crime. However, other studies found domestic violence offenders tend to have extensive criminal histories. To further investigate the extent to which partner assaults are part of a more general pattern of criminal behavior or a specialized type of crime, we studied the dating relationships of 653 university students. Thirty-one percent reported assaulting a partner in the previous 12 months. The rate of assault on partners by females did not differ significantly for males (29%) and females (32%). We also found high rates of other self-reported crime, and much higher rates by males. For example, over one half of the male students and almost one third of the female students reported having stolen money. The male students reported an average of 3.4 crimes committed, and the female students an average of 1.4 crimes. These high crime rates and gender differences are consistent with many previous studies. Logistic regression analysis revealed that a history of prior criminal acts is associated with an increased probability of assaulting a partner. The relationship was greater when there was prior violent crime compared to property crime, when there was early onset of criminal behavior, and when the offender was female. The implications of the findings for understanding partner assaults, criminal careers, and gender differences in the etiology of violence against intimate partners are discussed.

Understanding the nature and etiology of intimate partner violence and implications for practice and policy

“…Research has presented accounts of women's violence which has been interpreted as self-defense or in some way a reaction to men's IPV (Dasguta, 1999;Dobash et al, 1992;Dobash & Dobash, 1984;2004;Henning & Feder, 2004). More, empirically rigorous research has found little support for the primacy of self-defensive explanations for women's IPV (Gray & Forshee 1997;Stets & Straus 1990), particularly for those women who are violent towards non-violent male partners (Morse 1995;Simmons et al, 2005;Straus & Ramirez, 2004), or lesbian IPV (Dutton, 1994).…”

Substance-Abusing Female Offenders as Victims: Chronological Sequencing of Pathways Into the Criminal Justice System

“…They assume that age is a significant factor for understanding criminal behavior. By examining crime through a life-course perspective, we assume that the same event can have different consequences depending on when in the life course the event occurred (Strauss & Ramirez, 2004). For example, several studies have established the early onset of crime leads to a greater risk of prolonged criminal behavior (Glueck & Glueck, 1950; Sampson & Laub, 1993; Wolgang, 1983).…”

Cuatro consideraciones socioestadísticas para revisar la etiología del feminicidio en España

“…La hipótesis de que la conducta agresiva de las mujeres en la violencia en la pareja es meramente "de respuesta" a una agresión previa del varón ha quedado así mismo refutada por numerosas investigaciones (v.g. Anderson, 2002;Capaldi et al, 2004Capaldi et al, , 2007Cho, 2012;Straus y Ramírez, 2004;cfr. Dobash y Dobash, 2004).…”