Creating Representation in Support of Chemical Reasoning to Connect Macroscopic and Submicroscopic Domains of Knowledge

Abstract

Chemical reasoning takes many forms. The focus in this paper is on a reasoning process that facilitates using experimental evidence to make connections between macroscopic and submicroscopic domains, which we will refer to as creating representation. It is a particular type of reasoning that has played a critical role in chemistry, enabling numerous scientific advancements and discoveries. Yet, the skill of creating representation is often not explicitly addressed in our introductory classrooms or laboratories. This paper outlines a process for creating and using representation that builds on other constructivist approaches but is framed in a new way to afford consistency across a continuum of novice learners to expert scientists. We illustrate how this approach is enacted in the CORE laboratory learning cycle (Chemical Observations Representation Experimentation), where supports are provided to help students generate ideas about representation. We also illustrate how lab reports provide opportunities for reflection, which can generate new ideas leading to revision of a representation. A comparison of CORE with the Atkin and Karplus learning cycle is also included to show how these different learning opportunities engage students in complementary cognitive processes to promote chemical reasoning skills.

Contemplative Fridays: Mindfulness Pedagogy in the General Chemistry Classroom

“…The Contemplative Friday exercise could be expanded by allowing time for students to draw what they had visualized. The “drawing-to-learn” studies cited above indicate that doing so would enhance the educational benefits of the practice and help students connect the macroscopic and submicroscopic world in ways similar to those recently investigated by Bruce et al The downside is that the time required for drawing competes with “regular” class time. At the end of one of the Contemplative Friday exercises (one about picturing an oxygen atom), students were invited to draw what they had pictured during the exercise.…”

“…Above, the personal and educational benefits of mindfulness practices in higher education are documented. Complementary to those studies, there is ample evidence that visualizing chemical systems helps students learn chemistry. − While much of that literature focuses on students’ abilities to interpret images and animations created by others, a few reports indicate that having students build physical, 3D models of molecules and/or use computer modeling improves student performance on assessments. − Very recently, Steiff et al tested the effects of having students create their own drawing of chemical systems. They state that their results “indicate that drawing had a positive impact on how much students learned” and conclude that “drawing... clearly plays a primary role in facilitating learning.” These results support the 2020 meta-analysis of Cromley et al about “drawing-to-learn” strategies in the sciences, which included 53 peer-reviewed studies involving over 8000 participants .…”

Student-Generated Videos to Promote Understanding of Chemical Reactions

“…This concept is frequently represented with a triangle (Johnstone’s triangle) with the three apexes labeled with the macroscopic, submicroscopic, and symbolic terms. The model is also known as the chemistry triplet and has been widely used as the conceptual foundation for countless investigations in the field of chemical education. − The holistic Johnstone’s model shows its utility as a framework that allows students to establish relationships between the different components of its triangle. This continuous switch between the three levels is a sort of “mental gymnastics” which gives the student an overall view of the complex nature of chemistry.…”

A Web-Based Metallographic Atlas for Teaching Materials Science

“…Examples of their use in an online materials chemistry course were recently described by Ramachandran et al 8 It is important to note that many of these tools are increasingly being produced as open educational resources, offering many advantages for students and teachers. 9 Experiments play a pivotal role in teaching, 10 and virtual laboratory sessions have been demonstrated to be effective during the COVID-19 pandemic. 11 Two recent examples in the context of MS&E are the works by Schmidt et al 12 and Mussig et al 13 Textbooks are often insufficient under the highly dynamic conditions that develop during laboratory sessions in teaching metallography.…”

“…Experiments play a pivotal role in teaching, and virtual laboratory sessions have been demonstrated to be effective during the COVID-19 pandemic . Two recent examples in the context of MS&E are the works by Schmidt et al and Müssig et al Textbooks are often insufficient under the highly dynamic conditions that develop during laboratory sessions in teaching metallography.…”