Abstract:This article investigates how playwriting served three middle school Black girls within a larger practitioner research study seeking to better understand the literate practices of girls of color. It delves into the ways that playwriting provided the girls in an afterschool writing club opportunities to explore both their knowledge and ways of knowing, rooted in their cultural, gendered, and racialized experiences, and, in turn, share these with others, within an academic setting. It points to the necessity for… Show more
“…First, our findings underscore the primacy that digital technology holds over organizing sanctioned literacy practices, as well as how care and empathetic human intra-actions can decenter the role machines play within assemblages. Player (2019, p. 224), argues that literacy scholarship that centers on minoritized girls enables literacy scholars to understand the ways that oppressive practices harm girls of color, “as well as the ways that they are brilliant, agentive and passionate.” We illuminate the agency the girls exercised in finding alternate ways to participate that bolstered their subjectivities against institutional erasure. For example, in repositioning their bodies in relation to one another and the recording devices, Rhianna, Isa and Jillian agentically disrupted and subverted institutionalized discourses that position Black girls as less nurturing, less in need of protection, support and comfort than their white counterparts (Epstein et al , 2017; Richardson, 2009; Wun, 2018).…”
Purpose
This study aims to investigate the ways affective intensities arise in the intra-actions within an assemblage (three Black girls, objects such as computers and hoodies, institutionalized discourse associated with race and successful participation in schools) as the girls create multimodal responses to literature. This paper shows how the intra-actions among the girls and material objects produce affective intensities or new ways of being and becoming through which youth reauthor themselves as central and peripheral participants.
Design/methodology/approach
The authors present an illustrative case of the ways girls’ embodied literacy identities emerge when Jillian, Isa, and Rhianna intra-act with materials in an assemblage that includes their material-discursive positionings through qualitative and multimodal interaction analysis.
Findings
The analysis describes the ways the girls agentively participate through play, composing and moments of becoming (fluid subjectivities) that include emotive acts such as acts of solidarity, loving connectedness and possible frustration that inform who counts and who can be successful in the classroom.
Research limitations/implications
This single case study gives a descriptive, in-depth analysis of the ways affective intensities emerge as three girls respond to literature to understand their embodied and discursive practices within the composing process.
Originality/value
To fully understand agency and the students’ emergent subjectivities, the authors combine embodiment and material-discursive analysis to understand affective intensities that evolve during three Black girls’ composing processes and the ways the girls’ subjectivities shift within the intra-actions.
“…First, our findings underscore the primacy that digital technology holds over organizing sanctioned literacy practices, as well as how care and empathetic human intra-actions can decenter the role machines play within assemblages. Player (2019, p. 224), argues that literacy scholarship that centers on minoritized girls enables literacy scholars to understand the ways that oppressive practices harm girls of color, “as well as the ways that they are brilliant, agentive and passionate.” We illuminate the agency the girls exercised in finding alternate ways to participate that bolstered their subjectivities against institutional erasure. For example, in repositioning their bodies in relation to one another and the recording devices, Rhianna, Isa and Jillian agentically disrupted and subverted institutionalized discourses that position Black girls as less nurturing, less in need of protection, support and comfort than their white counterparts (Epstein et al , 2017; Richardson, 2009; Wun, 2018).…”
Purpose
This study aims to investigate the ways affective intensities arise in the intra-actions within an assemblage (three Black girls, objects such as computers and hoodies, institutionalized discourse associated with race and successful participation in schools) as the girls create multimodal responses to literature. This paper shows how the intra-actions among the girls and material objects produce affective intensities or new ways of being and becoming through which youth reauthor themselves as central and peripheral participants.
Design/methodology/approach
The authors present an illustrative case of the ways girls’ embodied literacy identities emerge when Jillian, Isa, and Rhianna intra-act with materials in an assemblage that includes their material-discursive positionings through qualitative and multimodal interaction analysis.
Findings
The analysis describes the ways the girls agentively participate through play, composing and moments of becoming (fluid subjectivities) that include emotive acts such as acts of solidarity, loving connectedness and possible frustration that inform who counts and who can be successful in the classroom.
Research limitations/implications
This single case study gives a descriptive, in-depth analysis of the ways affective intensities emerge as three girls respond to literature to understand their embodied and discursive practices within the composing process.
Originality/value
To fully understand agency and the students’ emergent subjectivities, the authors combine embodiment and material-discursive analysis to understand affective intensities that evolve during three Black girls’ composing processes and the ways the girls’ subjectivities shift within the intra-actions.
“…Ngo found that girls tended to place extra focus on the tensions around gender expectations between Hmong culture and U.S. values. In my own work in an after-school GOC writing program (Player, 2018(Player, , 2019(Player, , 2021, I found that GOC, including AsAm girls, used genre, such as playwriting and poetry, while tapping into raced, gendered epistemological resources to understand themselves as complex individuals with hybrid identities often ignored by dominant discourses. In work with AsAm girls in an intergenerational inquiry group, Ghiso, Campano, Player, Krishanwongso, and Gultom (2020) found that the girls used coalitional literate practices toward refusing assimilation and, in turn, committing to a shared commitment to educational equity.…”
Section: Asam Girl Literaciesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…3 Although beyond the scope of this article, in regard to solidarity, there were shared sentiments about the importance of relationships across difference, and commitment to understandings of concepts such as feminism were codeveloped by many of the Sisters across various identities. This work has been more fully explored in other articles about the Unnormal Sisterhood (Player, 2019(Player, , 2021.…”
In this article, I build off of AsianCrit, WOC, and AsAm feminisms, and theories of literacies that unpack dynamic processes of meaning making rooted in cultural, linguistic, gendered, and raced practices. Much of the theoretical basis of this article arises from possibilities forged by the work of Black and Latina theorists ho have developed frameworks to better under stand GOC and WOC beauty and brilliance. I stand with these scholars and with often obscured AsAm woman theorists "People Get Mistaken": Asian American Girls Using Multiple Literacies to Defy Dominant Imaginings of Asian American Girlhood | 433
“…This work sits in the company of scholars who have explored the ways Black girls resist and survive oppressive systems, including schooling, while also highlighting Black joy, creation, and ingenuity (Brown, 2009; 2013; Kelly, 2020; Richardson, 2007; Winn, 2011). The scholarship on Black girl literacies emphasizes the power of critical, humanizing, and multimodal pedagogies and how they can support educators in honoring the knowledge of Black girls (Player, 2019, 2021; Price-Dennis, 2016; Muhammad & Womack, 2015; Turner & Griffin, 2020). Further, this important work documents how Black girls are multifaceted, multidimensional, and have a variety of unique and intersecting identities that impact their lived realities and, thus, their literacies (Ife, 2017; Muhammad, 2015; Smith, 2016).…”
Section: Framing Girl Of Color Literaciesmentioning
This introduction to a special issue on Girl of Color literacies explores the editors’ purpose for creating the issue. Utilizing sociocultural definitions of literacy nuanced and bolstered by Women of Color theories of language and literacy, they establish an urgency to pursue research that is conducted with and for Girls of Color within the field of literacy. The editors articulate the goals of the special issue as well as provide proposed lines of inquiry the field must address to create research, pedagogies, and practices that are more loving toward Girls of Color and that honor their beautifully complex meaning-making practices.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.