COVID-19 pandemics modeling with SEIR(+CAQH), social distancing, and age stratification. The effect of vertical confinement and release in Brazil

Abstract

The ongoing COVID-19 epidemics poses a particular challenge to low and middle income countries, making some of them consider the strategy of "vertical confinement". In this strategy, contact is reduced only to specific groups (like age groups) that are at increased risk of severe disease following SARS-CoV-2 infection. We aim to assess the feasibility of this scenario as an exit strategy for the current lockdown in terms of its ability to keep the number of cases under the health care system capacity. We developed a modified SEIR model, including confinement, asymptomatic transmission, quarantine and hospitalization. The population is subdivided into 9 age groups, resulting in a system of 72 coupled nonlinear differential equations. The rate of transmission is dynamic and derived from the observed delayed fatality rate; the parameters of the epidemics are derived with a Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm. We used Brazil as an example of middle income country, but the results are easily generalizable to other countries considering a similar strategy. We find that starting from 60% horizontal confinement, an exit strategy on May 1st of confinement of individuals older than 60 years old and full release of the younger population results in 400 000 hospitalizations, 50 000 ICU cases, and 120 000 deaths in the 50-60 years old age group alone. The health care system avoids collapse if the 50-60 years old are also confined, but our model assumes an idealized lockdown where the confined are perfectly insulated from contamination, so our numbers are a conservative lower bound. Our results discourage confinement by age as an exit strategy.April 15, 2020

Mathematical model of COVID-19 intervention scenarios for São Paulo-Brazil

“…To fully understand the dynamic behavior of the virus on public health in a particular country, region, state, city, or organization it is important to consider factors such as testing rates and the availability of medical resources. Widespread testing is necessary to properly assess intervention strategies and allocate needed medical resources (6,7). However, laboratory testing to confirm exposure and/or diagnosis has been a major obstacle for the containment, mitigation, and suppression of COVID-19 worldwide.…”

“…These models may play an important role in helping governments and health providers prepare and combat the COVID-19 pandemic. For examples, prediction models may provide a framework for prototyping and studying possible intervention strategies and used as a guideline for when certain social distancing restrictions can be lifted (7).…”

A Spatial-Temporal Model for the Evolution of the COVID-19 Pandemic in Spain Including Mobility

“…As a consequence, most researchers directed their effort towards developing more fitting models, for instance, adding more compartments to the model such as pre-symptomatic, hospitalized, requiring intense care units, quarantined, isolated and exposed, isolated and infected, recovered or dead, see References [11][12][13][14], possibly leading to over-parameterized models. Other studies propose age-structured models that divide the population in classes depending on their age [15,16] or coupling them with available mobility data to study the effect of people's mobility in the spread of the disease [17,18]. This is the approach we will follow in this article.…”

Epidemiologically and Socio-economically Optimal Policies via Bayesian Optimization

“…Several works exist on modelling epidemic and pandemic progressions using differential equation-based models and using them to make predictions. Some examples include (Efimov and Ushirobira 2020;Lyra et al 2020;Sardar et al 2020;Vyasarayani and Chatterjee 2020). Most of these studies utilize differential equation-based models such as SIR and SEIR variants.…”