Countering the Narratives of Destruction: Textual Evidence and the Tradition of Heritage Preservation in Islam

Abstract

The relationship between Islam and cultural heritage preservation continually comes under scrutiny. This is because of vicious attacks on heritage and artefacts by groups laying claim to Islamic tenets and texts to justify their action. Thus, under this pretext, heritage sites and cultural actors and icons, are eliminated. Why is this so? What is the position of Islam on heritage preservation? How can the narratives of destruction be countered? This chapter interrogates these questions. It argues that the narratives of destruction derive from poor interpretations of the texts and traditions of Islam in respect of cultural heritage. Several monuments in the Islamic world also predate the establishment of Islam. The study brings out textual facts and traditions to counter the narratives of violent elements such as Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS), Al-Qaida, Boko Haram, Islamic State in West Africa Province (ISWAP) and Al-Qaida in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM).

On Colonial Monuments in the Post-colony: An Outline of the Problems of Populist Approaches in Managing Heritage in Southern Africa

“…The reason for this is that, just like the case with religious fundamentalists, the heritage ones also believe in the superiority of their own heritage symbols. They are also particular about their absolute disdain to coexist with other forms of heritage contradicting their beliefs (see Olaniyan & Bello, 2022). They are also reputed for their 'support or use of violence to achieve ideological, religious or political goals' (Ponce, 2019).…”