Counter‐Accounting with Invisible Data: The Struggle for Transparency in Myanmar's Energy Sector

Abstract

This article examines the counter-accounting methods one NGO, EarthRights International (ERI), uses to make Myanmar's notoriously opaque energy sector more transparent. ERI's methodological approach relies heavily on the identification of "invisible data," which do not appear in the statistics that governments and foreign energy companies release concerning their joint ventures. However, the data leave patterned traces in other statistical financial data. ERI asserts that it is possible to reconstruct joint venture balance sheets by comparing these traces against what the principles have not disclosed, such as with the controversial Yadana pipeline and the precedent-setting human rights lawsuit connected to it. The choices that ERI made illustrate how financial "facts" are fashioned rather than found, and that technical decisions regarding who does the counting, what gets counted, and what is disclosed to whom are profoundly political in nature. Such decisions also foreground key limitations of NGO-led revenue transparency projects, especially in resource-rich countries. Greater data disclosure does not necessarily result in increased transparency. Rather, the proliferation of structured and unstructured data sources (information that is organized and readily searchable versus information that is not) often leads to greater disagreement among key stakeholders regarding the relevance, neutrality, intelligibility, and verifiability of the numbers available for audit.

Mines and signs: resource and political futures in Bangladesh

“…The general excitement lasted until the 1990s, when it was revealed that no gas would be left by the second decade of the twenty‐first century unless new reserves were found. The impending crisis was either delayed or brought closer according to expert reports, supporting Timothy Mitchell's observation that organizing expert knowledge and methods of calculations of natural wealth are deeply politicized processes (Mitchell ; see also MacLean ). Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, the first President, had allegedly declined selling gas to Gazprom, the Soviet energy company, although the Soviet Union was one of the first countries to recognize Bangladesh.…”

Seeing (from) Digital Peripheries: Technology and Transparency in Kenya’s Silicon Savannah

“…“Most people are afraid and think it's a very insecure place.” Using the words real and transparent interchangeably to explain their mapping work, Kyale and his colleagues expressed faith in the maps as unmediated visual truth, on the one hand, and knowingly produced highly selective representations, on the other. This tension at the heart of transparency discourse—that revelation is always shadowed by concealment—has been well documented by social scientists (Strath‐ern ; Hetherington ; Mazzarella ; Levine ; MacLean ; Morris ). Less frequently considered, however, is how transparency‐seeking practices are informed by the subject positions of those who produce them.…”

“…Here, pace the dominant narrative in Nairobi's techno‐utopian social world, more information did not lead to more transparency (cf. MacLean ; Hetherington ). Indeed, what was at stake was the degree to which particular kinds of information became coded by various actors as transparent at all.…”