Cost Analysis of MRI Services in Iran: An Application of Activity Based Costing Technique

Abstract

Background:Considerable development of MRI technology in diagnostic imaging, high cost of MRI technology and controversial issues concerning official charges (tariffs) have been the main motivations to define and implement this study.Objectives:The present study aimed to calculate the unit-cost of MRI services using activity-based costing (ABC) as a modern cost accounting system and to fairly compare calculated unit-costs with official charges (tariffs).Materials and Methods:We included both direct and indirect costs of MRI services delivered in fiscal year 2011 in Shiraz Shahid Faghihi hospital. Direct allocation method was used for distribution of overhead costs. We used micro-costing approach to calculate unit-cost of all different MRI services. Clinical cost data were retrieved from the hospital registering system. Straight-line method was used for depreciation cost estimation. To cope with uncertainty and to increase the robustness of study results, unit costs of 33 MRI services was calculated in terms of two scenarios.Results:Total annual cost of MRI activity center (AC) was calculated at USD 400,746 and USD 532,104 based on first and second scenarios, respectively. Ten percent of the total cost was allocated from supportive departments. The annual variable costs of MRI center were calculated at USD 295,904. Capital costs measured at USD 104,842 and USD 236, 200 resulted from the first and second scenario, respectively. Existing tariffs for more than half of MRI services were above the calculated costs.Conclusion:As a public hospital, there are considerable limitations in both financial and administrative databases of Shahid Faghihi hospital. Labor cost has the greatest share of total annual cost of Shahid Faghihi hospital. The gap between unit costs and tariffs implies that the claim for extra budget from health providers may not be relevant for all services delivered by the studied MRI center. With some adjustments, ABC could be implemented in MRI centers. With the settlement of a reliable cost accounting system such as ABC technique, hospitals would be able to generate robust evidences for financial management of their overhead, intermediate and final ACs.

Costing the outpatient rehabilitation services: time-driven activity-based costing approach

“…In this regard, the use of the TDABC in this sector could be effective in determining the exact contribution of each type of human resources to the total cost. Studies in Iran have often considered lump sum personnel costs regardless of the time required to provide health care services [32,34], that is why the personnel cost makes up a large portion of total costs and makes health care services so expensive. Therefore, use of the TDABC method can be a remedy for controlling costs and price inflation in the health sector.…”

Inappropriateness of brain MRI prescriptions and its financial burden

“…Given the high importance of doing MRI in diagnosis and treatment procedure, high cost of purchasing and maintaining MRI machines for centers and also high cost of using MRI for patients and health insurers (13), the appropriateness of brain MRI prescriptions and its related factors were investigated in this study.…”

Prevention and control of non-communicable diseases in iran: the case for Investment

“…83% of deaths in the country occur due to NCDs [1,4]. The country faces an increase in its elderly population, a trend not seeming to decline in the near future, signaling a pressing need for provident planning [5][6][7][8]. Of the ten leading causes of mortality in the country, eight are classified as NCDs, ischemic heart diseases being the most prevalent, seeing an increase of 29.9% in the last ten years.…”