Correlation of passivity symptoms and dysfunctional visuomotor action monitoring in psychosis

Abstract

Passivity experiences are hallmark symptoms of schizophrenia that can be characterized by the belief that one's thoughts or actions are controlled by an external agent. It has recently been suggested that these psychotic experiences result from defective monitoring of one's own actions, i.e. disturbed comparison of actions and perceived outcomes. In this study, we examined the function of the previously characterized action monitoring network of the inferior parietal lobule (IPL), medial (mPFC) and lateral prefrontal cortices in patients with different levels of passivity symptoms with an fMRI task. The visuomotor fMRI task demanded control of visually perceived object movements by alternating button presses with the left and the right index finger. In the monitoring condition of this task subjects stopped their actions whenever they detected visuomotor incongruence. fMRI and behavioural data from 15 patients were tested for correlation with passivity symptoms using standardized Scale for Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS)- and AMDP- passivity symptom ratings. Both types of data were tested for differences between the patients group and 15 healthy controls. In the patient group we found the expected correlation of passivity symptoms and visuomotor monitoring performance. There was a significant positive correlation of passivity symptoms with increased latency of incongruence detection and a negative correlation of SAPS-passivity with the number of detected events. fMRI data revealed correlations of passivity symptoms with activation in bilateral IPL, primary motor and sensory cortices in the action monitoring condition. A correlation of passivity symptoms with the main experimental effect (actions with – actions without monitoring) was found in the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC) and in the left IPL. No group differences or group by task interactions were found within the visuomotor-action-monitoring network. Our results demonstrate the association between passivity symptoms and the dysfunction of visuomotor action monitoring and support the idea that psychotic passivity experiences result from dysfunctions of central action monitoring mechanisms: According to pre-existing concepts of parietal cortex function, IPL-hyperactivation may represent an increase in false detections of visuomotor incongruence while the correlation between passivity and the differential effect of monitoring on PCC-activation assumedly represents greater self-monitoring effort in passivity experiences.

Does the salience network play a cardinal role in psychosis? An emerging hypothesis of insular dysfunction

“…116 Positron emission tomography and fMRI studies have also found abnormalities in the activation of the insula in addition to brain regions involved in action monitoring in patients with passivity symptoms. 117,118 Consistent with a study by Crespo-Facorro and colleagues, 22 a recent study from our group has shown significant correlation between the volume of the salience network and severity of delusions and hallucinations. 119 Insular volume is related to other aspects of psychopathology as well.…”

Mentalizing Functions Provide a Conceptual Link of Brain Function and Social Cognition in Major Mental Disorders

“…Studying motor-sensory self-monitoring of schizophrenia patients, we actually found a link between the psychotic impairment of self-other discrimination and the motor-sensory determination of agency [63]. Such deficits of motor sensory self-other discrimination were linked to the occurrence of ego disturbances and to a hyperactivation of motion-sensitive parietal cortices.…”

Further Evidence for the Impact of a Genome-Wide-Supported Psychosis Risk Variant in ZNF804A on the Theory of Mind Network

“…Abnormal activation has repeatedly been observed to be associated with misinterpretations of other's actions in schizophrenia (Brunet-Gouet and Decety, 2006) and to correlate with typical psychotic symptomatology, that is, the experience of alien control over self-initiated movements (Schnell et al, 2008). The anterior temporal cortex has frequently been implicated in ToM abnormalities in schizophrenia patients as well (Lee et al, 2006;Park et al, 2009Park et al, , 2011.…”