“…As a result, the calculated yields of gas hydrocarbons from oil cracking are increasingly underestimated with oil/coal ratio when fixed yields of gas hydrocarbons from coal cracking are used. For the third, the yields of gas hydrocarbons from oil cracking could decrease with oil/coal ratio because coal played a catalytic role for oil cracking (e.g., Greensfelder et al, 1949;Smith et al, 1989;Alexander et al, 2009Alexander et al, , 2011Asif et al, 2009Asif et al, , 2010Berwick et al, 2011), and therefore, a high ratio of oil to coal obviously reduces this catalytic effect. The variation in trends of ratios (OC/O) for wet gases with oil/coal ratio in the experiments of coal A plus oil can be accounted for by the second and third factors.…”