Good syn-selectivities are obtained by addition of a di-tbutyl zincate reagent derived from a propargylic amine to aldehydes.The stereochemistry of the addition of allenic-propargylic organometallic reagents to aldehydes is widely attributed to the existence of two transition states, a cyclic one affording the anti-adduct or an open one affording the synadduct (Scheme 1). 1 As shown in Scheme 1, the cyclic transition state involves the activation of the aldehyde by the Lewis acidic metal of the organometallic reagent. Poor with lithium and Grignard derivatives, 2 the anti-selectivity is good with titanium, zinc, chlorostannyl, chlorosilyl and indium derivatives. 3 With non-Lewis acidic organometallic reagents such as trialkylstannyl or silyl derivatives and in the presence of an external Lewis acid, a synselective addition is obtained via the open transition state. 4
Scheme 1We have recently re-examined the diastereoselective addition of organozinc reagents (AZnBr), derived from the propargylic amine 1, to aldehydes. As expected, the antiaminoalcohols were obtained with good selectivities via the cyclic transition state (entry 1, Table 1). 5 To our knowledge no methodology affording syn-aminoalcohols from metallated propargyl amines is available. We postulated that any change in the Lewis acidity of the organometallic reagent would have a dramatic effect on the stereochemistry of this reaction. Accordingly, a lithiocyanocuprate was prepared and added to aldehydes. Unexpectedly anti-aminoalcohols were obtained with a better selectivity than with zinc derivatives. 5 The zincates reagents are often compared to cuprates in terms of reactivity 6 but a recent paper from Nakamura has pointed out the structural differences between these two 'ate' complexes. 7 Moreover, to our knowledge, no study on the addition of allenylzincates reagents to aldehydes has been performed so far. Therefore we decided to study the effect of the nature (AZnBr, AZnR, AZnR 2 , Scheme 2) of the zinc reagents derived from 1 on the stereochemistry of this reaction. First, isobutyraldehyde was added to the allenyl-Zn-butyl (AZnBu) reagent (Scheme 3), prepared as shown in Scheme 2, to give, in a good yield, the amino alcohol 2a in 82:18 ratio in favor of the anti-adduct (entry 2, Table 1). Therefore, the switch of AZnBr into AZnBu induced a slight decrease of the anti-selectivity (compare entries 1 and 2 in Table 1). No significant change in the selectivity was observed with AZnt-Bu (entry 3).
Scheme 2 Preparation of zinc reagentsThe zincate reagent AZnEt 2 was then prepared from the lithio derivative by addition of diethylzinc (Scheme 2). To the purple solution of zincate was slowly added, at -85°C, a THF solution of isobutyraldehyde (Scheme 3, entry 4). It is interesting to note that, during the addition, a decoloration was observed indicating that the reaction was instantaneous. The aminoalcohol 2a was obtained in good yield and in a 1:1 syn:anti ratio. Therefore, the transformation of AZnBu into AZnEt 2 resulted in a decrease of the anti-select...