Convergent parallel mixed-methods study to understand information exchange in paediatric critical care and inform the development of safety-enhancing interventions: a protocol study

Abstract

IntroductionThe effective exchange of clinical information is essential to high-quality patient care, especially in the critical care unit (CCU) where communication failures can have profoundly negative impacts on critically ill patients with limited physiological capacity to tolerate errors. A comprehensive systematic characterisation of information exchange within a CCU is needed to inform the development and implementation of effective, contextually appropriate interventions. The objective of this study is to characterise when, where and how healthcare providers exchange clinical information in the Department of Critical Care Medicine at The Hospital for Sick Children and explore the factors that currently facilitate or counter established best rounding practices therein.Methods and analysisA convergent parallel mixed-methods study design will be used to collect, analyse and interpret quantitative and qualitative data. Naturalistic observations of rounds and relevant peripheral information exchange activities will be conducted to collect time-stamped event data on workflow and communication patterns (time–motion data) and field notes. To complement observational data, the subjective perspectives of healthcare providers and patient families will be gathered through surveys and interviews. Departmental metrics will be collected to further contextualise the environment. Time–motion data will be analysed quantitatively; patterns in field note, survey and interview results will be examined based on themes identified deductively from literature and/or inductively based on the data collected (thematic analysis). The proactive triangulation of these systemic, procedural and contextual data will inform the design and implementation of efficacious interventions in future work.Ethics and disseminationInstitutional research ethics approval has been acquired (REB #1000059173). Results will be published in peer-reviewed journals and presented at relevant conferences. Findings will be presented to stakeholders including interdisciplinary staff, departmental management and leadership and families to highlight the strengths and weaknesses of the exchange of clinical information in its current state and develop user-centred recommendations for improvement.

Challenges of caring for the aged: Attracting and retaining aged care assistants in Western Australia

“…Drawing on the two‐pronged ‘convergent parallel’ model, 9 qualitative and quantitative data were collected concurrently and analysed separately, following human research ethics approval (Permit No. # RDBS‐10‐16) from Curtin University.…”

Focusing the Safety Spotlight: How Safety Intelligence Can Inform Systemic Patient Safety Initiatives

“…Similarly, the critical care unit within Toronto's Hospital for Sick Children has been collaborating with human factors experts to understand complex interactions of work system elements that influence the exchange of clinical information within their unit. Knowledge of their current clinical work system is being cultivated proactively to generate evidence for the development and implementation of effective and appropriate interventions (Tomasi et al, 2018).…”

Doctors documenting: an ethnographic and informatics approach to understanding attending physician documentation in the pediatric emergency department

“…Mixed-methods approaches provide great value to studies utilizing SEIPS, with qualitative and quantitative data providing rich context to explore and understand the complex layers of healthcare. 38,39 Stemming from the field of anthropology, ethnography (particularly, focused ethnography 40,41 ) is the methodological, systematic study of people, their thoughts, and behaviors and affords both qualitative and quantitative data collection through participatory observation. 42,43 Complementary to human factors, the ethnographic approach has been long-used in the field of system design 43 and its virtue is that it illuminates a real-world setting through direct involvement by the researcher.…”