Control Group Design: Enhancing Rigor in Research of Mind-Body Therapies for Depression

Abstract

Although a growing body of research suggests that mind-body therapies may be appropriate to integrate into the treatment of depression, studies consistently lack methodological sophistication particularly in the area of control groups. In order to better understand the relationship between control group selection and methodological rigor, we provide a brief review of the literature on control group design in yoga and tai chi studies for depression, and we discuss challenges we have faced in the design of control groups for our recent clinical trials of these mind-body complementary therapies for women with depression. To address the multiple challenges of research about mind-body therapies, we suggest that researchers should consider 4 key questions: whether the study design matches the research question; whether the control group addresses performance, expectation, and detection bias; whether the control group is ethical, feasible, and attractive; and whether the control group is designed to adequately control for nonspecific intervention effects. Based on these questions, we provide specific recommendations about control group design with the goal of minimizing bias and maximizing validity in future research.

Outcomes of a randomized controlled trial of nutrition education to promote farmers’ market fruit and vegetable purchases and consumption among women enrolled in the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC)

“…There may have been little room for improvement in participants' fruit intake and possibly a need for greater emphasis in the WFS lesson on the promotion of vegetable intake. A strength of using an active control group in the WFS trial was the ability to control for attention, time, and expectations regarding the lesson received; a disadvantage, however, was that it may have been more difficult to detect an intervention effect [29]. It has been suggested that providing individuals with any active intervention content is likely to lead to some change in behavior [30].…”

Ict Enabled Implementation of Strategy - Empirical Evidence From Serbian Customs Service

“…This group of scientific control enables the experimental study of one variable at a time, and it is an essential part of the scientific method. In a controlled experiment, two identical experiments are carried out: in one of them, the treatment or tested factor (experimental group) is applied; whereas in the other group (control), the tested factor is not applied (Kinser & Robins, 2013). …”

Computerized auditory cognitive training to improve cognition and functional outcomes in patients with heart failure: Results of a pilot study

“…Use of an active control group is preferred. 74,75 Hence, future studies should include an active control design to fully evaluate benefits of ACT. Due to the small sample size we did not consider significance testing.…”