Contextualizing “religion” of young Karl Marx: A preliminary analysis

Abstract

Like any other social category, the meaning and conceptual boundary of “religion” is ambiguous and contentious. Historically speaking, its semantics have been transformed in highly complex ways. What is meant by “religion” reflects the specific norms and imperatives of the classifier. This article critically reflects upon the idea of “religion” employed by Karl Marx in the early 1840s. Marx reimagined the encompassing notion of “religion,” which was predominant in his time, by privatizing it in his attempt to critique the theological foundation of the Prussian state. In this process, young Marx’s discourse siphons what is claimed to be “religious” out of the categories of “philosophy,” “science,” and “politics.” In this way, Marx constructs the realm of nonreligion where he associates his own discourse with natural reason, against the reified notion of “religion” as fantastic illusions.

Religious Socialism Gives Birth to a Dynamic World: A Critical Review of Dialectical Materialism and Historical Materialism

“…The result of these two ideas has long been regarded as an authoritarian political ideology rife with aggression (Hama 2019). Despite the fact that Marx's theory has been widely criticized by scientists and other philosophers, scientific practitioners in this century, including Indonesian scholars, have paid close attention to it (Carver 1972;Chitty 2011;Choat 2016;Cocks 1983;Doel 2008;Farihah 2015;Graham 1993;Horii 2017;Hudis 2004;Jordan and Macmillan 1967;Megill and Park 2017;Niemi 2011;van Ree 2020;Sinn 2017).…”

Reviewing Poverty in Indonesia: Karl Marx's View of Religion Is an Opium

“…This thought is reflected in his own assertion that religion is the opium of society (Munir 2016). Marx envisioned religion as a fantastical illusion consumed by individuals because of its euphoric effects such as opium (Horii, 2017). It was in this unease that Karl Marx declared Religion to be alienation; Religion is opium (Lutfi & Khairullah, 2019).…”