Contested Environmental Hazards and Community Conflict Over Relocation*

Abstract

The majority of the literature on contaminated communities indicates that environmental hazards lead to conflict and dissension. In this paper we examine the salient dimensions of conflict and factionalism in a rural Oklahoma community. The community is heavily contaminated from 80 years of commercial mining operations and was one of the first sites designated on the Environmental Protection Agency's Superfund List in 1983. Despite two decades of remediation efforts, the community remains polluted with lead and other heavy metals. Based on in-depth interviews with community residents, observation, and document analysis, we find that the community has splintered into two competing groups over the environmental controversy. One faction of the community supports a federally sponsored relocation campaign, while the other has organized to oppose relocation. The results of our study indicate that the contentious split is centered around the ambiguity of harm associated with the contamination, conflicting economic concerns, and variations in community attachment.

Rebuild or Relocate? Resilience and Postdisaster Decision‐Making After Hurricane Sandy

“…Still, taken together, the lack of significance of these individual-level predictors is surprising, particularly with regard to tenure, exposure (Myers et al 2008), 5 and the presence of children in the home (Fraser et al 2003;Shriver and Kennedy 2005), which have been found previously to influence the decision to remain in or leave one's home. The implication here is that residents' perceptions of their broader community were more influential in the buyout decision than were their experiences of Sandy, or their personal or family characteristics.…”

Toxic Space and Time: Slow Violence, Necropolitics, and Petrochemical Pollution

“…This is not to say that communities are indifferent to the contested threats of pollution-the myriad claims of bodily harm associated with Cancer Alley testifies to that-but it is notably rare for toxic uncertainty to be translated into meaningful legal action or challenges to the compartmentalized geography of this industrialized space. Environmental justice victories in Louisiana and other polluted regions are therefore the exception rather than the rule, and collective inaction is a far more common occurrence (Shriver and Kennedy 2005;Auyero and Swistun 2009;Neumann 2016).…”

Family Structures, Relationships, and Housing Recovery Decisions after Hurricane Sandy

“…Place attachment is generally defined as having two major constituents: place identity, which refers to residents' self-perception of their identity relative to their surrounding physical environment, and place dependence, which refers to residents' self-perception of the community's potential to address their needs [45,48,49].…”