Contestations and complexities of nurses’ participation in policy-making in South Africa

Abstract

BackgroundThere has been increased emphasis globally on nurses’ involvement in health policy and systems development. However, there has been limited scholarly attention on nurses’ participation in policy-making in South Africa.ObjectiveThis paper analyses the dynamics, strengths, and weaknesses of nurses’ participation in four national health workforce policies: the 2008 Nursing Strategy, revision of the Scope of Practice for nurses, the new Framework for Nursing Qualifications, and the Occupation-Specific Dispensation (OSD) remuneration policy.DesignUsing a policy analysis framework, we conducted in-depth interviews with 28 key informants and 73 frontline nurses in four South African provinces. Thematic content analysis was done using the Atlas.ti software.ResultsThe study found that nurses’ participation in policy-making is both contested and complex. The contestation relates to the extent and nature of nurses’ participation in nursing policies. There was a disjuncture between nursing leadership and frontline nurses in their levels of awareness of the four policies. The latter group was generally unaware of these policies with the exception of the OSD remuneration policy as it affected them directly. There was also limited consensus on which nursing group legitimately represented nursing issues in the policy arena. Shifting power relationships influenced who participated, how the participation happened, and the degree to which nurses’ views and inputs were considered and incorporated.ConclusionsThe South African health system presents major opportunities for nurses to influence and direct policies that affect them. This will require a combination of proactive leadership, health policy capacity and skills development among nurses, and strong support from the national nursing association.

Voices from the frontline: barriers and strategies to improve tuberculosis infection control in primary health care facilities in South Africa

“…As noted by Gilson [ 49 ], it is the frontline workers who “ultimately translate policy intentions into practice”, and this speaks to the importance of involving PHC nurses and managers in decision making. Despite this, there is a dearth of studies that explore nurses’ participation in broader health workforce policies [ 50 ]. Hence our study adds value as it allows PHC nurses and managers to provide their insights into strategies that could improve TB infection control.…”

Nursing education reform in South Africa – lessons from a policy analysis study

“…The study reported in this paper was part of a larger project to examine the dynamics, strengths, and weaknesses of nursing policy-making in South Africa ( 32 ). It constitutes one of four policies of focus identified at a broad consultative workshop held with key nursing stakeholders ( 33 ).…”

Transforming nursing policy, practice and management in South Africa

“…In the third paper within this theme, Ditlopo et al ( 13 ) analyse the dynamics, strengths, and weaknesses of nurses’ participation in four national health workforce policies: the 2008 Nursing Strategy, revision of the Scope of Practice for nurses, the new Framework for Nursing Qualifications, and the Occupation-Specific Dispensation (OSD) remuneration policy. The study found that nurses’ participation in policy-making is both contested and complex ( 13 ). There was a disjuncture between nursing leadership and front-line nurses in their levels of awareness of the four policies ( 13 ).…”

“…The study found that nurses’ participation in policy-making is both contested and complex ( 13 ). There was a disjuncture between nursing leadership and front-line nurses in their levels of awareness of the four policies ( 13 ). There was also limited consensus on which nursing group legitimately represented nursing issues in the policy arena ( 13 ).…”