Consumer debt holding, income and happiness: evidence from China

Abstract

PurposeThe relationship between debt and happiness is an emerging research topic with significant implications for both theory and practice in economics and business. In China, where the consumer credit market is at an early stage of development, the topic remains under-investigated and the evidence on the debt–well-being link is scarce. The purpose of this study is to examine the association between debt holding and happiness and the moderating role of income in it.Design/methodology/approachData used in the study were from three waves (2013, 2015 and 2017) of the China Household Finance Survey. Fixed-effect regressions on panel data were used for data analyses.FindingsThe results show that any type of debt holding is negatively associated with happiness. Among seven specific types of debts, four types show negative associations with happiness, which in the order from higher to lower associations, are medical, education, other and housing debt. In addition, negative associations between debt holding and happiness vary among income groups. The results suggest that any debt holding potentially decreases happiness for low- and middle-income consumers only. In addition, holdings of three specific types of debts (medical, education and housing debt) may decrease happiness for both low- and middle-income consumers, and holding two types of debts (business and other debt) may decrease happiness for middle-income consumers only.Research limitations/implicationsData used in this study originate from one country only. It limits the generalizability of findings to other countries with different institutional backgrounds and different socio-economic characteristics of populations. The results have implications for researchers who study consumer debt behavior and business practitioners who do businesses with Chinese companies and consumers.Practical implicationsChina is an emerging economy that is at the early stage of credit market development. The results of this study provide helpful information and insights for business practitioners to explore credit markets and serve credit product clients with various income levels in China.Social implicationsThe results of this study are informative for public policies. When introducing credit market-related policies, policymakers should pay attention to people's happiness and to differential welfare effects of holdings of different types of debts and among consumers with various levels of incomes.Originality/valueUnique contributions of this study include using data from the most recently available waves of the China Household Finance Survey (2013, 2015 and 2017) to study the associations between debt holding and happiness. In addition, the findings of this study enrich the literature of debt and happiness by adding evidence from China, the largest emerging economy in the world, which is helpful for future theory building and business practice on the relationship between debt holding and happiness.

Past, present and future of bank marketing: a bibliometric analysis of International Journal of Bank Marketing (1983–2020)

“…Second, in terms of consumer behavior in banking and financial services, this study sheds light on the importance of market segmentation and investor sentiments, as well as the financial offerings and services provided to consumer segments. Noteworthily, this is the second most popular area of research in bank marketing, and its proliferation in recent years has coincided with increasing public concerns and sentiments around consumer debt Yao, 2014, 2020;Xiao et al, 2021) and socially responsible banking and financial services that enhance financial literacy (Xiao and Porto, 2017) and personal financial management (Goyal et al, 2021). Future research in this direction is expected to continue given the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on consumer finances.…”

Education, Income, and Happiness: Evidence From China

“…Zhang and Liu ( 40 ) used the cross-sectional data of the 2010 China Comprehensive Social Survey (CGSS) to find that the level of happiness of Chinese people with high education is higher than that of people with low education. In addition, individuals will try to compare living standards with their peers, and higher income and wealth means more material happiness ( 41 ). However, while China's economy is growing rapidly, income inequality has also increased significantly, and happiness increases with the increase in income inequality ( 42 ).…”

Good credit, bad credit: The differential role of the sources of debt in life satisfaction

“…The analysis also included markers of economic situation, such as per capita household incomes (after log transformation), possession of savings, and labor market status, as they have been shown to moderate impact of debt on well‐being (Xiao et al . 2021). Finally, each analysis controlled for the baseline wave in each cross‐section.…”

“…Chronic illness, BMI, smoking, and alcohol consumption all increase the chance of a health shock, which is likely to impact life satisfaction as well as to change the consumption patterns by increasing coping strategies, especially borrowing (Babiarz et al 2013;Kim et al 2012). The analysis also included markers of economic situation, such as per capita household incomes (after log transformation), possession of savings, and labor market status, as they have been shown to moderate impact of debt on wellbeing (Xiao et al 2021). Finally, each analysis controlled for the baseline wave in each crosssection.…”