Enzymes
have long been characterized for their specificity and
efficiency in catalyzing one substrate to one product. However, a
SnoaL-like cyclase (XimE) that was originally discovered in xiamenmycin
biosynthesis not only catalyzes the pyran-forming cyclization of the
natural epoxide metabolites generated by XimD, but also enhances the
furan-forming cyclization of the unnatural epoxide isomer. We have
investigated and elucidated the reaction mechanism for this potentially
unique substrate control of enzyme function. We explored the plausible
pathways occurring at the hydrophobic active sites with a combination
of theozyme (a small cluster model) calculations, pre- and post-reaction
molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, ONIOM(ωB97X-D/6-31G(d):AMBER)
transition state searching, and QM/SCRF(VS) dielectric constant scanning.
Both the pyran and furan pathways share similar general acid–base
catalytic mechanisms in which E136 and H102 act as proton donor and
acceptor, respectively; pyran is generated by a fused-TS that proceeds
via a general-acid-catalyzed mode, while furan is generated via a
spiro-TS catalyzed by a general-base-catalyzed mode. The relative
energies of the four possible transition states were found by ONIOM
calculations to be Fused-S ≲ Spiro-S < Spiro-R < Fused-R. The
regiochemical preference of the XimE-catalyzed pyran formation from S-epoxide and furan formation from R-epoxide
stems from the induced-fit interaction between the enzyme and its
transition states, which carries over to products. XimE apparently
evolved along with the natural S-epoxide substrate generated by the
upstream XimD epoxidase, and accidentally is also able to catalyze
a different reaction of the enantiomeric R-epoxide
via a similar catalytic mechanism.