Constraining Ω₀with the Angular Size–Redshift Relation of Double‐lobed Quasars in the FIRST Survey

Abstract

In previous attempts to measure cosmological parameters from the angular size-redshift (θ-z) relation of double-lobed radio sources, the observed data have generally been consistent with a static Euclidean universe, rather than with standard Friedmann models, and past authors have disagreed significantly as to what effects are responsible for this observation. These results and different interpretations may be due largely to a variety of selection effects and differences in the sample definitions destroying the integrity of the data sets, and inconsistencies in the analysis undermining the results. Using the VLA FIRST survey, we investigate the θ-z relation for a new sample of double-lobed quasars. We define a set of 103 sources, carefully addressing the various potential problems which, we believe, have compromised past work, including a robust definition of size and the completeness and homogeneity of the sample, and further devise a self-consistent method to assure accurate morphological classification and account for finite resolution effects in the analysis. Before focusing on cosmological constraints, we investigate the possible impact of correlations among the intrinsic properties of these sources over the entire assumed range of allowed cosmological parameter values. For all cases, we find apparent size evolution of the form l ∝ (1 + z) c with c ≈ −0.8 ± 0.4 which 1 ari@astro.columbia.edu 2 djh@astro.columbia.edu 3 bob@igpp.llnl.gov 4 rlw@stsci.edu is found to arise mainly from a power-size correlation of the form l ∝ P β (β ≈ −0.13 ± 0.06) coupled with a power-redshift correlation. Intrinsic size evolution is consistent with zero. We also find that in all cases, a subsample with c ≈ 0 can be defined, whose θ-z relation should therefore arise primarily from cosmological effects. These results are found to be independent of orientation effects, though other evidence indicates that orientation effects are present and consistent with predictions of the unified scheme for radio-loud active galactic nuclei. The above results are all confirmed by non-parametric analysis.Contrary to past work, we find that the observed θ-z relation for our sample is more consistent with standard Friedmann models than with a static Euclidean universe. Though the current data cannot distinguish with high significance between various Friedmann models, significant constraints on the cosmological parameters within a given model are obtained. In particular, we find that a flat, matter-dominated universe (Ω 0 = 1), a flat universe with a cosmological constant, and an open universe all provide comparably good fits to the data, with the latter two models both yielding Ω 0 ≈ 0.35 with 1σ ranges including values between ∼ 0.25 and 1.0; the c ≈ 0 subsamples yield values of Ω 0 near unity in these models, though with even greater error ranges. We also examine the values of H 0 implied by the data, using plausible assumptions about the intrinsic source sizes, and find these to be consistent with the currently accepted range of values. We dete...

Ultra-compact structure in intermediate-luminosity radio quasars: building a sample of standard cosmological rulers and improving the dark energy constraints up to z ~ 3

“…In the similar spirit, radio sources constitute a specially powerful population to test the redshift -angular size relation for extended FRIIb galaxies (Daly & Djorgovski 2003), radio galaxies (Guerra & Daly 1998;Guerra, Daly & Wan 2000), and radio loud quasars (Buchalter et al 1998). For instance, it was firstly proposed that the canonical maximum lobe size of radio galaxies may provide a standard ruler for cosmological studies.…”

Measuring the speed of light with ultra-compact radio quasars

“…Recently efforts have also been made to explore the sizes of galaxy clusters at different redshifts, by using radio observations of the Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect together with X-ray emission (De Filippis et al 2005;Bonamente et al 2006). In similar spirit, powerful radio sources have served as a special population to test the redshift -angular size relation for extended FRIIb galaxies (Daly & Djorgovski 2003), radio galaxies (Guerra, Daly & Wan 2000), and radio loud quasars (Buchalter et al 1998). More promising candidates in this context are ultra-compact structures in radio sources (especially in quasars that can be observed up to very high redshifts), with milliarcsecond angular sizes measured by the very-long-baseline interferometry (VLBI) (Kellermann 1993;Gurvits 1994); for details regarding the respective definitions of angular size see Data.…”

Improved constraints on the cosmological parameters using the VLA FIRST survey

“…However, due to the survey resolution limit, uncertainties in the quasar optical positions, variations in the morphologies of double-lobed sources, and inspection of numerous FIRST radio maps, we also introduce an effective cutoff in the data of 12 ′′ , shown in Fig. 2, following Buchalter et al (1998), below which an accurate morphological classification could not be assigned with certainty. Such a cutoff ensures that we do not include the so called core-jet, diffuse, cometary and other type of extended radio sources that may be mistaken for double-lobed objects at low resolution.…”