Eight Catholic school communities across Australia nominated teacher identity characteristics aligned with an understanding of Catholic school mission from a local community perspective. A data mining process (Leximancer, 2017) of the collated narratives from focus groups (n = 73) highlighted the mission concept, School, with a frequency of 295 appearances. An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) of the concept revealed characteristics of tradition, integration and participation and characterized their essence as 'a shared sacred mission'. Participant utterances that referenced teacher characteristics and frequencies within the narrative focused on: Community (38), Faith (13), and Life (9). Community utterances identified teacher 'connections with students,' 'staff relationships,' 'associations with the broader community,' and 'involvement in the life of the school.' Faith was expressed in teacher 'leadership,' 'Gospel values,' 'spiritual growth,' 'experience of church and connection with the charism of the Religious Institute.' Life involved teachers advancing student 'welfare,' 'service,' 'tradition,' and 'advocacy.' Overall, teacher identity characteristics integral to mission were discussed as Relationship Agency, Equity and Authenticity. Relational Agency entailed facilitation of student capabilities; Relationship Equity enacted social justice values of inclusion and respect; and Relationship Authenticity advanced and witnessed a foundational meaning system aligned with Catholic school tradition. The implications of the findings identified a case for relationships as being pertinent to mission for all teachers in Catholic schools, but teachers of Religious Education in particular.