We would like to thank Jillian Galle for organizing the session at the 2011 meeting of the Society for Historical Archaeology of which this paper was a part and for her continuing research assistance. Karen Smith supplied context information about the pierced coins and horn ring found at Monticello, and we are grateful for her help. Brad Hatch assisted with organizing tables, and his thesis provided a valuable source of comparative data. Crystal Ptacek drafted Figure 1. Dennis Pogue and Doug Sanford read and commented extensively on earlier drafts of this paper. Their critiques helped us to clarify our arguments and re-evaluate our initial emphases. Lori Lee and Mark Freeman provided valuable suggestions as did anonymous reviewers for NEHA.