Considerations on the Mechanism of Action of Artemisinin Antimalarials: Part 1 - The 'Carbon Radical' and 'Heme' Hypotheses

Abstract

The isolation of artemisinin from the traditional medicinal herb qīng hāo (Artemisia annua), its characterization as a peroxide and preparation of the derivatives dihydroartemisinin, artemether and artesunate in the 1970s and 1980s by Chinese scientists under the umbrella of Project 523 collectively represents one of the great events in medicine in the latter third of the 20(th) Century. Artemisinins have become the most important component of chemotherapy of malaria: although used initially in monotherapy, they are now used in combination therapies or ACTs with longer half-life quinolines or arylmethanols. Nevertheless, the recent emergence of artemisinin-tolerant strains of the malaria parasite as reflected in increased clearance times of parasitaemia in patients treated with ACTs represents the greatest threat to control of malaria since resistance to chloroquine was first reported over 55 years ago. Importantly, the event brings into sharp focus the realization that relatively little is precisely understood, as opposed to widely assumed, for the mechanism of drug action of artemisinins and their synthetic peroxide analogues. Thus, we review here their antimalarial activities, the use of artemisinins in combination therapies, drug-drug interactions with the quinolines and arylmethanols, and metabolism of the artemisinins and synthetic peroxides. The mechanism of action of quinolines and arylmethanols, in particular their ability to induce redistribution of heme into the parasite cytosol, is also highlighted. This collective information is then used as a counterpoint to screen the validity of two of the prevailing hypotheses of drug action of artemisinins and synthetic peroxides, namely i. 'the C-radical hypothesis' wherein the peroxide undergoes 'bioactivation' by ferrous iron to generate C-radicals that are held to be the cytotoxic agents and ii. the 'heme hypothesis' wherein ferrous heme may generate either the same type of 'cytotoxic' C-radical, or the peroxide forms heme adducts that apparently inherit the exquisite cytotoxicities of the parent peroxide in one way or another. In a subsequent review, we screen the third and fourth hypotheses: the SERCA hypothesis wherein artemisinins modulate operation of the malaria parasite sarcoendo plasmic reticulum calcium pump SERCA Ca(2+)-ATPase ATP6 and the co-factor hypothesis wherein artemisinins act as oxidant drugs through rapidly oxidizing reduced conjugates of flavin cofactors, or those of flavin cofactor precursors such as riboflavin, and other susceptible endogenous substrates that play a role in maintaining intraparasitic redox homeostasis. For the C-radical hypothesis, details of in vitro chemical studies in the context of established chemistry of C-radicals and their ability to react with radical trapping agents such as nitroso compounds, cyclic nitrones, persistent nitroxyl radicals and atmospheric oxygen (dioxygen) are summarized. Overall, there is no correlation between antimalarial activities and abilities of the derived C-radicals to react with trapp...

In vitro anti-cancer effects of artemisone nano-vesicular formulations on melanoma cells

“…Although it remains to be precisely established how artemisone exerts its cytotoxic effect, it is very likely that it enhances generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) [12,13] and, as in other cases involving selective cytotoxicity in cancer cells induced by oxidative stress [36,37,38] …”

“…Subsequently, it was found to be active against other parasites [6], and to possess antitumour properties [7,8,9,10]. Although the mechanism of action is popularly ascribed to cytotoxic free radicals arising via reaction of iron with the peroxide within the 1,2,4-trioxane [11], it is more likely that the intrinsic oxidant properties of the peroxide perturb intracellular redox homeostasis by interrupting electron flow to crucial intracellular reductants such as glutathione responsible for maintaining redox homeostasis in the stressed environment of the pathogen, a process that will be enhanced in the presence of iron [12,13].…”

Preliminary Evaluation of Artemisinin–Cholesterol Conjugates as Potential Drugs for the Treatment of Intractable Forms of Malaria and Tuberculosis

“…Significantly,i th as been shown that attachment of lipophilic steroidal groups to tetraoxanesp rovides compounds such as 6 that are also strikingly active against Mtb (Figure 2). [14] However,t he evident cytotoxicity of these compounds precludes their further development Under ap rogram designed to developn ew triple drug combinations for the treatment of malaria, tuberculosis, and toxoplasmosis, [15] we are preparing and evaluating efficacieso f drug combinations whichh ave oxidanta nd redox properties, respectively [16] coupled with at hird partnerw ith ad ifferent mode of action. The third partner drug being considered in the first instance incorporates a4 (1H)-quinolones caffold.…”

The protective effect of Moringa oleifera leaf extract on liver damage in mice infected with Plasmodium berghei ANKA

“…Additionally, accumulation of toxic free heme from erythrocyte destruction during malaria infection could induce oxidative stress from the hydroxyl radical production via Fenton/Harber-Weiss reaction followed by liver injury [18]. Moreover, during malaria infection, overproduction of oxidized low density lipoprotein can trigger adverse effect in vascular lesion, reactive oxygen species, and liver cell damage [19].…”