Conservation and crime convergence? Situating the 2018 London Illegal Wildlife Trade Conference

Abstract

The 2018 London Illegal Wildlife Trade (IWT) Conference was the fourth and biggest meeting on IWT convened at the initiative of the UK Government. Using a collaborative event ethnography, we examine the Conference as a site where key actors defined the problem of IWT as one of serious crime that needs to be addressed as such. We ask (a) how was IWT framed as serious crime, (b) how was this framing mobilized to promote particular policy responses, and (c) how did the framing and suggested responses reflect the privileging of elite voices? Answering these questions demonstrates the expanding ways in which thinking related to crime and policing are an increasingly forceful dynamic shaping conservation-related policy at the global level. We argue that the conservation-crime convergence on display at the 2018 London IWT Conference is characteristic of a conservation policy landscape that increasingly promotes and privileges responses to IWT that are based on legal and judicial reform, criminal investigations, intelligence gathering, and law enforcement technologies. Marginalized are those voices that seek to address the underlying drivers of IWT by promoting solutions rooted in sustainable livelihoods in source countries and global demand reduction. We suggest that political ecology of conservation and environmental crime would benefit from greater engagement with critical criminology, a discipline that critically interrogates the uneven power dynamics that shape ideas of crime, criminality, how they are politicized, and how they frame policy decisions. This would add further conceptual rigor to political ecological work that deconstructs conservation and environmental crime.Keywords: illegal wildlife trade, poaching, conservation, crime, event ethnography, criminology

Criminología verde, esfuerzo de aplicación de las regulaciones sobre vida silvestre en México entre el 2006 y 2020

“…En la ecología política, pese a analizar temas de conservación ecológica y biopolítica, la aplicación de la ley se utiliza poco, sobre todo en crímenes de vida silvestre, y de no emplearse, podría invisibilizar una comprensión crítica de las formas de poder asociadas con la vigilancia institucional (Massé, F., 2019). La ecología política se beneficiaría de la criminología verde, pues no sólo necesita interrogar críticamente y dar cuenta del privilegio de cierto conocimiento e ideas sobre la conservación, sino también debe deconstruir los discursos del crimen y la vigilancia que convergen en el crimen de conservación (White, R., 2013;McGarrell, E. y Gibbs, C., 2014;Massé, F., et al, 2020).…”

Building a global taxonomy of wildlife offenses

“…A taxonomy is important to revising legislation. For example, concern about the social and ethical impacts of overcriminalization (Duffy et al, 2019;Masse et al 2020) has prompted calls to allow more legal, sustainable wildlife use (e.g., Challender et al, 2015;PNP, 2020). Related legal reforms would require revisions across legislation to clarify rights, establish processes (e.g., permits) and set standards (e.g., quotas).…”

Doing feminist collaborative event ethnography

“…Starting in the 1960s, meetings like COP21 and WCC have become normative spaces to debate and make decisions about global environmental governance, structuring discourses and creating policies that have high impact in communities around the globe. Global environmental governance sites are comprised of complex and expansive networks of actors with multiplicities of identities, ranging from nation-states, to non-governmental organizations (NGOs), industry partners, and other invested stakeholders (Brosius and Campbell 2010;MacDonald 2010;Massé et al 2020;O'Neill 2017). The UNFCCC meetings, the World Conservation Congress, the World Parks Congress, and the Convention of Biological Diversity are just a few examples of sites of global environmental governance that meet regularly to debate and determine environmental goals and outcomes.…”