“…Huthnance (1982aHuthnance ( , 1982b implemented scarcity as a non-erodible layer and hypothesized that scarcity was required for equilibrium cross-sections to exist, but later studies with more realistic hydrodynamics (e.g., Roos et al, 2004; showed that this was not the case. Regarding other bedforms, sand scarcity was shown to decrease height and width, increase wavelength and three-dimensionality in shape, and affect the migration rate of tidal (Nnafie et al, 2023;Porcile et al, 2017) and fluvial dunes (Dreano et al, 2010;Endo, 2016;Kleinhans et al, 2002;Tuijnder et al, 2009;Vah et al, 2020). However, these bedforms are driven by flow circulations in the vertical plane (Hulscher, 1996;Paarlberg et al, 2009;Vittori & Blondeaux, 2020) rather than the residual circulations in the horizontal plan that drive tidal sandbanks (Figure 1).…”