Consent Forms, Lower Reading Levels, and Using Flesch-Kincaid Readability Software

Abstract

The US Food and Drug Administration requires the use of a consent form as part of the protection of human subjects in clinical trials. To help increase the probability of consent form comprehension, the biopharmaceutical industry, FDA, National Cancer Institute, and National Institutes of Health often advise developing consent forms between a sixth and eighth grade reading level. Frior studies have examined consent comprehension at different reading levels. However, prior study results are often inconsistent, do not all utilize consents conforming to the code of Federal Regulations (CFR), and do not all report the validity or reliability of the comprehension measurement t d used or the studies' sample populations that are homogeneous and possess limiting characteristics. Thus the question remains whether lowering the reading level of a CFR-conforming consent fonn increases comprehension in a population devoid of predefined characteristics. Also unanswered is whether other variables, together or separate-Iy such as age, gender, income level, and prior exposure to consent forms affect comprehension of consent forms written at different reading levels.To establish baseline research regarding the comprehension-reading level relationship, a study was petformed utilizing a heterogeneous population of individuals waiting for jury ser-vice. The eflects on comprehension by age, income, gender, prior exposure to consent forms, and 6th versus loth grade reading level consents were examined. The consent forms' reading levels were determined using the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level scale in Microsoft Word.Comprehension was measured using a validated Ls-question multiple-choice questionnaire that subjects completed after reading the consent forms. Statistical analysis of the effects by age and consent level on comprehension resulted in a significant main effect on comprehension by age, but no eflect by consent level. A comparison indicated that only the 30-44 and 60-75 age groups demonstrated significant differences in comprehension. An analysis of the eflects on comprehension by gender, income, and consenting to research in the past resulted in no significant main or interaction effects. Additional analysis confirmed that only age significantly affcted comprehension. The research concluded that gender, income, prior exposure to consent forms, and lowering consent reading level had no effect on comprehension, and comprehension was only afected by age after the age of 60. This study also confirmed that when used as a preliminary tod, scanning a consent form using the Flesch-Kincaid Index in Microsoft Word can prove effecve for developing consent forms-

Readability and understandability of clinical research patient information leaflets and consent forms in Ireland and the UK: a retrospective quantitative analysis

“…49 Furthermore, another study showed that increasing readability level, as measured by FKGL, does not enhance comprehension, although the authors still felt that the Microsoft Word version of the FKGL is a useful tool for the initial assessment of a PIL. 50 In contrast, another study which randomised patients to receive a standard information leaflet or a leaflet with a lower FKGL which also added comparative tables and emphasised key information, to promote colorectal screening, found that recognition of information improved with the adjusted text. 51 Peterson improved readability according to automated readability scores but found that most assessors preferred a document which had been edited graphically only.…”

Improved informed consent documents for biomedical research do not increase patients’ understanding but reduce enrolment: a study in real settings

“…Data were analyzed using Review Manager (RevMan) v5.2.7. Briefly, we included 14 published randomized controlled trials evaluating modified ICDs for clinical research [11,12,[17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28], whether tested in simulated or in real conditions, and we added the results of the present study.…”

Depressive Symptoms, Acute Alcohol Intoxication, and Risk Rationale Effects on Men’s Condom Use Resistance

“…After reaching the target BrAC, participants read a sexually explicit scenario of approximately 1,600 words at a 5 th -grade reading level as determined by Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (Kincaid, Fishburne, Roger, & Chissom, 1975; Walters & Hamrell, 2008). The scenario was pilot tested and modified for clarity and realism to participants’ lives.…”