Consent, coercion and autonomy: Underage sex work in Aotearoa New Zealand

Abstract

INTRODUCTION:Adolescents' involvement in sex work in New Zealand has been associated with a range of adverse effects on physical, psychological, and social well-being, and is framed by domestic legislation and international obligations. AIM:The study aimed to ascertain the nature of adolescents' experiences of sex work, and how their current and past environments impacted on their understanding of their involvement in sex work. METHODS:Semi-structured interviews were used with a sample of eight adolescents aged 16-20 who became involved with sex work between ages 12 and 16. FINDINGS:The study found that participants' exposure to physical and sexual abuse in childhood had informed their internal working models of normative gendered behaviour. These models were then reinforced by exposure to the gendered power differential inherent in the sex work sub-culture. Participants experienced sexual experiences as being solely dictated by men, and frequently normalised transgressions against physical and/or sexual integrity. CONCLUSION:The prevalence and acceptance of gendered harm among this population group indicates the need to appropriately address vulnerable adolescents' abuse histories, challenge restrictive conceptions of gender, and actively combat the pervasive presence of gendered violence and inequality among this population group.

The Human Rights of Sex Trafficking Survivors: Trends and Challenges in American Vacatur Laws

“…That report found that there was no substantial difference in the violence or sexual abuse suffered by sex workers in the country and 35% of sex workers stated that they had been coerced into prostitution. On the issue of trafficking, several scholars have strongly denied and contested claims that there has been no trafficking in New Zealand since the passage of the PRA, see, e.g., [19,20]. These scholars point to two key elements to counter claims that sex trafficking has decreased in or disappeared from New Zealand.…”

“…There is no official screening process for the identification of victims and, therefore, no possibility of such victims securing access to needed medical, psychological, social, or legal resources. Some of these scholars even argue that the continued discourse about the lack of trafficking in New Zealand means that any disclosures by trafficking victims are likely to be misinterpreted and ignored [19].…”

To send or not to send nudes: New Zealand girls critically discuss the contradictory gendered pressures of teenage sexting

“…It has been argued that unsolicited dick pics are a form of online sexual harassment, yet the normalisation of men's sexual intrusions may mean they are not always framed as such (Hayes & Dragiewicz, 2018;Salter, 2016;Thorburn, 2018). Although several participants described persistent requests for nudes and unsolicited sexual images as unwanted and annoying, they did not often speak about these interactions in a way that made strong links to sexual harassment and gendered abuse.…”

Capital Accrual and Constraints: Domestic Sex Trafficking Victims’ Negotiation of Vicarious and Feminized Capital

“…The precursors to this marginality (such as histories of abuse or abandonment) create immense vulnerability, which is identified and capitalized on by traffickers who can entice victims with promises of basic essentials and emotional security (Dorais & Corriveau, 2009; Hanna, 2002; Parker & Skrmetti, 2013; Reid, 2016). However, it is unknown to what extent this is the case in Aotearoa New Zealand, although research into underage sex work suggests that histories of abuse and family marginality are instrumental in shaping adolescent girls’ entry into self-facilitated sex work (Thorburn, 2016).…”