Marine gastropods of the genus
Conus
are renowned for their remarkable diversity and deadly venoms. While
Conus
venoms are increasingly well studied for their biomedical applications, we know surprisingly little about venom composition in other lineages of Conidae. We performed comprehensive venom transcriptomic profiling for
Conasprella coriolisi
and
Pygmaeconus traillii
, first time for both respective genera. We complemented reference-based transcriptome annotation by a
de novo
toxin prediction guided by phylogeny, which involved transcriptomic data on two additional ‘divergent’ cone snail lineages,
Profundiconus
, and
Californiconus
. We identified toxin clusters (SSCs) shared among all or some of the four analysed genera based on the identity of the signal region—a molecular tag present in toxins. In total, 116 and 98 putative toxins represent 29 and 28 toxin gene superfamilies in
Conasprella
and
Pygmaeconus
, respectively; about quarter of these only found by semi-manual annotation of the SSCs. Two rare gene superfamilies, originally identified from fish-hunting cone snails, were detected outside
Conus
rather unexpectedly, so we further investigated their distribution across Conidae radiation. We demonstrate that both these, in fact, are ubiquitous in Conidae, sometimes with extremely high expression. Our findings demonstrate how a phylogeny-aware approach circumvents methodological caveats of similarity-based transcriptome annotation.