Conflict and negotiation in intergenerational care: Older women’s experiences of caring with the Old Age Grant in South Africa

Abstract

Social policy and welfare provision have converged with socio-economic conditions, cultural beliefs about kin support and intra-household dynamics to position older women as important financial providers in their families. This article draws on the findings of a qualitative study about intergenerational relationships of care in a large township near Cape Town. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with fourteen female Old Age Grant recipients and some of their co-resident adult children. The article focuses on the grant recipients’ experiences of giving and receiving financial support (‘financial care’) in their intergenerational relationships. It also unpacks the intra-household dynamics involved in this caregiving. Although the grant better enabled the women in the study to meet the needs of their households, beliefs about the mutual and shared responsibility for financial caregiving in families informed their expectations of financial assistance from younger kin. When their co-resident younger relatives did earn an income, negotiations around the provision of financial care ensued; generating conflict and reflecting unequal power relations between relatives. These dynamics contributed to the women’s experiences of vulnerability and their high burden of care. In this context, the article examines the state’s role in the care process and how it has contributed to the gendered and generational distribution of care work in families.

“A frightening experience, especially at our age”: Examining the neglect and abuse of older persons in HIV prevention and care programs

“…As has been shown in other settings, many older persons face financial, transport, and long-distance challenges to access health services ( 61 ). Approximately 3.7 million people aged 60 years and older in South Africa receive a non-contributory old-age pension ( 70 ). This merger pension is in most cases used to support the entire household including adult children ( 71 ).…”

Gender Differences in Social Support Vary by Environment Among Older People With HIV in South Africa and Uganda

“…Women in South Africa reported frequent family support, but this support had a negative side: Nearly half reported being upset by their family in the past month. Financial responsibilities involving the old age pension are one potential source of conflict ( Button & Ncapai, 2019 ). Fewer than half the women reported having a functional friend.…”

Conceptualisations of “good care” within informal caregiving networks for older people in rural South Africa

“…Enelo was one of many caregivers who received reciprocal support from care recipients through childcare and/or “financial care” ( Button & Ncapai, 2019 , 560). Yet caregivers did not acknowledge this reciprocity; they masked the financial care they received from care recipients, subtly implying that their caregiving was not motivated by financial need, and perpetuating altruism as the ideal motivation.…”