Concept of defensive medicine and litigation among Sudanese doctors working in obstetrics and gynecology

Abstract

BackgroundObstetrics and gynaecology always has reputation for being a highly litigious. The field of obstetrics and gynaecology is surrounded by different circumstances that stimulate the doctors to practice defensive medicine.MethodsThis study was directed to assess the extent and the possible effect of defensive medicine phenomenon (in term of knowledge and prevalence) on medical decision making among different grades of obstetric and gynaecologic Sudanese doctors, and to determine any experience of medical litigations with respect to sources and factors associated with it (in term of area of work, characteristics of the area at which the doctors worked, professionalism, hospitals systems…ect).ResultsA total of 117 doctors were approached, their distribution according to job description was as follow: consultants (42.7 %, 50\117) registrars (34.2 %, 40\117) and specialists (23.1 %, 27\117). The majority 89.7 % had the impression that litigation against doctors are increasing and 27.6 % had a direct experience of litigation. In this study less than one half (42.7 %) of the surveyed doctors knew the concept of defensive medicine and 71.8 % reported practicing one or another form of defensive medicine. The different sources of the litigations reported by the doctors included: maternal death (n = 15), perinatal death (n = 5), other {misdiagnosis, intra-uterine fetal death, uterine perforation, rupture uterus} (n = 4), fetal distress (n = 3), injury to viscera (n = 3) and shoulder dystocia (n = 2). In this study the experience of medical litigation was significantly observed among those who worked in area of blame culture (90.6 % Vs 56.5 %, P = 0.000). In logistic regression model, there was no significant difference between those who knew the concept of defence medicine and those who didn’t.ConclusionThere should be strategic plan to reduce the practice of defensive medicine and medical litigation against doctors.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12910-016-0095-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The first survey on defensive medicine among Iranian surgeons: prevalence and its related factors

“…About 91.1% of surgeons believed that DM behaviors, especially diagnostic tests, led to higher health costs, which may reduce the referrals [22] and lead to discontinuation of treatment, or even may put patients at high risk including exposure to radiation. In addition, 58.1% of Iranian surgeons were aware of the DM, which was consistent with the findings of study from Sudan [23].…”

The attitudes towards defensive medicine among physicians of obstetrics and gynaecology in China: a questionnaire survey in a national congress

“…According to numerous reports, most physicians have practised or have been practising defensive medicine. 7–11 According to a survey of physicians in Pennsylvania, defensive medicine is highly prevalent among various specialties who pay the most for liability insurance. 12 In China, it is reported that physicians' previous experience with medical disputes is significantly associated with defensive behaviours, particularly with overprescription.…”

Defensive medicine and cesarean sections in Brazil

“…[ 75 ] Usually in countries where plural democracy predominates, such as America, Oceania and Europe, the legal system tends to favor the practice of defensive medicine. [ 23 , 76 ] However, defensive medicine is also causing concerns in many other regions of the world, [ 21 , 34 , 77 , 78 ] including countries with different political regimes than plural democracies. The Islamic Republic of Iran, for example, in addition to having a high rate of CS, [ 79 ] also has a high frequency of DM, [ 80 ] and obstetric litigation in this country reduces the tendency of doctors to perform vaginal deliveries.…”