Concentrations of 45 Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in North American River Otters (Lontra canadensis) from West Virginia, USA
Zhong-Min Li,
Anna Roos,
Thomas L. Serfass
et al.
Abstract:North American river otters (Lontra canadensis) are top predators in riverine ecosystems and are vulnerable to
per- and polyfluoroalkyl substance (PFAS) exposure. Little is known
about the magnitude of exposure and tissue distribution of PFAS in
river otters. We measured 45 PFAS in various tissues of 42 river otters
collected from several watersheds in the state of West Virginia, USA.
The median concentrations of ∑All (sum concentration of 45
PFAS) varied among tissues in the following decreasing order: liver
… Show more
“…Three fluorotelomer sulfonates (FTSs) were analyzed in this study; 8:2 FTS was detected in 19/20 otters, 6:2 FTS in 2 otters, and 4:2 FTS was not detected. These are similar to detection frequencies to those found in the liver of American river otters (Lontra canadensis, 79%, 12%, and 0%, respectively) . 8:2 FTS had the third highest median concentration and the highest maximum concentration of the replacement compounds (median: 0.817 μg/kg ww, maximum: 70.3 μg/kg ww, Figure d); this is higher concentrations seen in Eurasian otters from Europe (maximum: 14.5 μg/kg ww) and American river otters (maximum: 1.87 μg/kg ww) .…”
Section: Resultssupporting
confidence: 78%
“…These are similar to detection frequencies to those found in the liver of American river otters ( Lontra canadensis , 79%, 12%, and 0%, respectively). 32 8:2 FTS had the third highest median concentration and the highest maximum concentration of the replacement compounds (median: 0.817 μg/kg ww, maximum: 70.3 μg/kg ww, Figure 3 d); this is higher concentrations seen in Eurasian otters from Europe (maximum: 14.5 μg/kg ww) 23 and American river otters (maximum: 1.87 μg/kg ww). 32 FTSs have been used as PFOS replacements in a wide variety of products 17 , 20 , 65 but are probably excreted quickly, 32 and FTSs degrade to PFCAs in the environment and biota.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 88%
“…8:2 FTS had the third highest median concentration and the highest maximum concentration of the replacement compounds (median: 0.817 μg/kg ww, maximum: 70.3 μg/kg ww, Figure d); this is higher concentrations seen in Eurasian otters from Europe (maximum: 14.5 μg/kg ww) and American river otters (maximum: 1.87 μg/kg ww) . FTSs have been used as PFOS replacements in a wide variety of products ,, but are probably excreted quickly, and FTSs degrade to PFCAs in the environment and biota. , The rate of degradation increases with decreasing fluoroalkyl chain length under ultrasound thermolysis experiments, and this may explain the higher detection frequency of 8:2 FTS compared with 6:2 and 4:2 FTS.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 93%
“…F-53B is formed of two components: F-53B major and F-53B minor; in our study, F-53B major was detected in 19 of the 20 otters with concentrations up to 1.33 μg/kg ww, and F-53B minor was detected in 6 otters with concentrations up to 0.13 μg/kg ww. F-53B major has been previously reported in surface water and sediment samples in the UK , and in one otter from the UK at a concentration of 3.3 μg/kg ww and in American otter liver at a maximum concentration of 0.06 μg/kg ww . F-53B is not manufactured in the UK or EU, usage of the chemical is not known, and it is not registered under the EU or UK REACH Regulations, so no single company can be importing it in quantities exceeding 1 tonne/year .…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Liver was selected as the optimum tissue for comparability with previous studies, 23 , 24 , 32 and because detection in liver has been shown to be higher than other tissues and therefore more likely to be of a detectable concentration. 32 Otter selection was restricted to a transect running east away from the PTFE manufacturing facility on the Fylde coast, North England. A sample of 20 livers from otters which died between 2015 and 2019 were selected for analysis ( Figure 1 ).…”
Concentrations of 33 PFASs were determined in 20 Eurasian otters, sampled 2015−2019, along a transect away from a factory, which used PFOA in PTFE manufacture. Despite cessation of usage in 2012, PFOA concentrations remained high near the factory (>298 μg/kg ww <20 km from factory) and declined with increasing distance (<57 μg/kg ww >150 km away). Long-chain legacy PFASs dominated the Σ 33 PFAS profile, particularly PFOS, PFOA, PFDA, and PFNA. Replacement compounds, PFECHS, F-53B, PFBSA, PFBS, PFHpA, and 8:2 FTS, were detected in ≥19 otters, this being the first report of PFBSA and PFECHS in the species. Concentrations of replacement PFASs were generally lower than legacy compounds (max: 70.3 μg/kg ww and 4,640 μg/ kg ww, respectively). Our study underscores the utility of otters as sentinels for evaluating mitigation success and highlights the value of continued monitoring to provide insights into the longevity of spatial associations with historic sources. Lower concentrations of replacement, than legacy, PFASs likely reflect their lower bioaccumulation potential, and more recent introduction. Continued PFAS use will inevitably lead to increased environmental and human exposure if not controlled. Further research is needed on fate, toxicity, and bioaccumulation of replacement compounds.
“…Three fluorotelomer sulfonates (FTSs) were analyzed in this study; 8:2 FTS was detected in 19/20 otters, 6:2 FTS in 2 otters, and 4:2 FTS was not detected. These are similar to detection frequencies to those found in the liver of American river otters (Lontra canadensis, 79%, 12%, and 0%, respectively) . 8:2 FTS had the third highest median concentration and the highest maximum concentration of the replacement compounds (median: 0.817 μg/kg ww, maximum: 70.3 μg/kg ww, Figure d); this is higher concentrations seen in Eurasian otters from Europe (maximum: 14.5 μg/kg ww) and American river otters (maximum: 1.87 μg/kg ww) .…”
Section: Resultssupporting
confidence: 78%
“…These are similar to detection frequencies to those found in the liver of American river otters ( Lontra canadensis , 79%, 12%, and 0%, respectively). 32 8:2 FTS had the third highest median concentration and the highest maximum concentration of the replacement compounds (median: 0.817 μg/kg ww, maximum: 70.3 μg/kg ww, Figure 3 d); this is higher concentrations seen in Eurasian otters from Europe (maximum: 14.5 μg/kg ww) 23 and American river otters (maximum: 1.87 μg/kg ww). 32 FTSs have been used as PFOS replacements in a wide variety of products 17 , 20 , 65 but are probably excreted quickly, 32 and FTSs degrade to PFCAs in the environment and biota.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 88%
“…8:2 FTS had the third highest median concentration and the highest maximum concentration of the replacement compounds (median: 0.817 μg/kg ww, maximum: 70.3 μg/kg ww, Figure d); this is higher concentrations seen in Eurasian otters from Europe (maximum: 14.5 μg/kg ww) and American river otters (maximum: 1.87 μg/kg ww) . FTSs have been used as PFOS replacements in a wide variety of products ,, but are probably excreted quickly, and FTSs degrade to PFCAs in the environment and biota. , The rate of degradation increases with decreasing fluoroalkyl chain length under ultrasound thermolysis experiments, and this may explain the higher detection frequency of 8:2 FTS compared with 6:2 and 4:2 FTS.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 93%
“…F-53B is formed of two components: F-53B major and F-53B minor; in our study, F-53B major was detected in 19 of the 20 otters with concentrations up to 1.33 μg/kg ww, and F-53B minor was detected in 6 otters with concentrations up to 0.13 μg/kg ww. F-53B major has been previously reported in surface water and sediment samples in the UK , and in one otter from the UK at a concentration of 3.3 μg/kg ww and in American otter liver at a maximum concentration of 0.06 μg/kg ww . F-53B is not manufactured in the UK or EU, usage of the chemical is not known, and it is not registered under the EU or UK REACH Regulations, so no single company can be importing it in quantities exceeding 1 tonne/year .…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Liver was selected as the optimum tissue for comparability with previous studies, 23 , 24 , 32 and because detection in liver has been shown to be higher than other tissues and therefore more likely to be of a detectable concentration. 32 Otter selection was restricted to a transect running east away from the PTFE manufacturing facility on the Fylde coast, North England. A sample of 20 livers from otters which died between 2015 and 2019 were selected for analysis ( Figure 1 ).…”
Concentrations of 33 PFASs were determined in 20 Eurasian otters, sampled 2015−2019, along a transect away from a factory, which used PFOA in PTFE manufacture. Despite cessation of usage in 2012, PFOA concentrations remained high near the factory (>298 μg/kg ww <20 km from factory) and declined with increasing distance (<57 μg/kg ww >150 km away). Long-chain legacy PFASs dominated the Σ 33 PFAS profile, particularly PFOS, PFOA, PFDA, and PFNA. Replacement compounds, PFECHS, F-53B, PFBSA, PFBS, PFHpA, and 8:2 FTS, were detected in ≥19 otters, this being the first report of PFBSA and PFECHS in the species. Concentrations of replacement PFASs were generally lower than legacy compounds (max: 70.3 μg/kg ww and 4,640 μg/ kg ww, respectively). Our study underscores the utility of otters as sentinels for evaluating mitigation success and highlights the value of continued monitoring to provide insights into the longevity of spatial associations with historic sources. Lower concentrations of replacement, than legacy, PFASs likely reflect their lower bioaccumulation potential, and more recent introduction. Continued PFAS use will inevitably lead to increased environmental and human exposure if not controlled. Further research is needed on fate, toxicity, and bioaccumulation of replacement compounds.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.