Computed tomography of the chest in unilateral pleural effusions: outcome of the British Thoracic Society guideline

Abstract

Background: The guidelines from the British Thoracic Society (BTS) regarding the investigation of unilateral pleural effusions recommend computed tomography (CT) in exudates. We decided to investigate if clinicians follow BTS guidelines' recommendations with respect to CT in patients with unilateral pleural effusions. Secondly, to investigate the diagnostic consequences of following and not following this recommendation. Methods: The study was a retrospective, non-randomized study including consecutive patients referred to our tertiary centers in 2013-2016 because of unilateral pleural effusion. Patients undergoing chest CT for unilateral pleural effusion of unknown cause after thoracentesis and chest X-ray were included. Patients were categorized as having pleural exudates or transudates, according to Light's criteria, if applicable. We registered use of CT, and calculated diagnostic values. Results: In total, 323 of the 465 included patients underwent CT (69%). CT was performed in the majority of patients not having an exudate (transudates: n=40; 54%; Light's criteria not assessed: n=111; 67%). 18 F-FDG positron emission tomography (PET)/CT without prior CT was performed in 32 patients with an exudate (58%). The sensitivity of a non-guideline supported CT (70%) was significantly higher compared to a guideline supported CT (47%), P value <0.045. The post-test probability of a positive guideline-supported CT [likelihood ratio (LR) positive 3.26] for a later diagnosis of thoracic malignancy increased the probability from 25% to 52%. A negative CT (LR negative 0.62) decreased the probability to 17%. For a non-guidelinesupported CT the numbers were (LR positive 3.42) 53% and (LR negative 0.38) 11%, respectively. Conclusions: Clinicians appear not to follow BTS guidelines when deciding to perform chest CT. The relevance of this deviation is supported by the superior sensitivity of CT non-guideline supported CT. Overall, CT is associated with suboptimal sensitivity and negative predictive values for the diagnosis of thoracic malignancy.

CT Scan Characteristics in Patients Referred with Pleural Effusion: Discriminating between Tuberculosis and Malignancy in a Middle East Country

“…In addition, CT scan scoring system has been raised for years as a reliable way to confirm malignant pleural effusion diagnosis through some works such as Burnazovic-Ristic's (6). On the contrary, some do not rely on CT scan due to suboptimal sensitivity and other diagnostic characteristics like negative predictive value in thoracic malignancy (7). The purpose of current study was to assess CT scan findings in patients with any kind of pleural effusion to obtain any diagnostic value of this modality of imaging to discriminate malignant conditions from benign ones, especially pleural or pulmonary tuberculosis.…”

Implementation of evidence on management of pleural diseases: insights from a territory-wide survey of clinicians in Hong Kong

“…In particular, there are major breakthroughs in the understanding, investigation and treatments of common pleural diseases [ 6 ], which can reduce morbidity and improve quality of care for patients. However, the incorporation of major advances into clinical practice can vary tremendously across different healthcare systems [ 7 , 8 ], and there are a number of possible barriers contributing to the insufficient update and lack of implementation of guidelines and advances [ 9 ].…”