Computational Mechanism Study of Catalyst-Dependent Competitive 1,2-C→C, −O→C, and −N→C Migrations from β-Methylene-β-silyloxy-β-amido-α-diazoacetate: Insight into the Origins of Chemoselectivity

Abstract

Doyle et al. [J. Am. Chem. Soc.201313512441247] recently reported an efficient catalyst-controlled chemoselectivity of competitive 1,2-C→C, −O→C, and −N→C migrations from β-methylene-β-silyloxy-β-amido-α-diazoacetates using dirhodium or copper catalysts. With the aid of density functional theory calculations, the present study systematically probed the mechanism of the aforementioned reactions and the origins of the catalyst-controlled chemoselectivity. Similar to the method reported in the literature, simplified catalyst models Rh2(O2CH)4 and Rh2(N-methylformamide)4 have been used in our initial calculations. However, using the Rh2(O2CH)4 model could not describe the energies of all possible pathways, and high selectivity of three competitive migrations could not be achieved. In order to appropriately describe this 1,2-migration system, real catalyst models Rh2(cap)4, Rh2(esp)2, and CuPF6 have been employed. It was found that the steric and electronic effects of ligands significantly influence the free energy barrier, which ultimately changes the chemoselectivity. In the CuPF6 system, the electronic effects, coupled with the steric factor, give a qualitative explanation for the exclusive chemoselectivity of 1,2-N→C migration over 1,2-C→C or −O→C migration. On the other hand, the bulky ligands of dirhodium catalysts result in the significant steric hindrance around the dirhodium centers and withdrawal of the empty space around the bulky −OTBS group. By analyzing the divergence of three different migration transition states using the distortion/interaction and natural bond orbital analyses, it was found that the 1,2-N→C migration will suffer from a high free energy barrier because of the steric repulsion between the carbonyl group and the carbonyl oxygen of the pyrazolidinone ring. For 1,2-C→C and −O→C migrations, changing the ligands of dirhodium catalysts can change the electronic properties of carbenes, and that is the reason for controlling the major product by changing the dirhodium catalysts. The mechanistic proposal is supported by the calculated chemoselectivities, which are in good agreement with the experimental results.

DFT Studies on the Dirhodium-Catalyzed [3 + 2] and [3 + 3] Cycloaddition Reactions of Enol Diazoacetates with Isoquinolinium Methylide: Mechanism, Selectivity, and Ligand Effect

“…In 2015, Xue et al studied a cyclopropanation reaction catalyzed by the achiral catalysts Rh 2 (OAc) 4 and Rh 2 (S-PTTL) 4 using the B3LYP-D3 method and found that the dirhodium catalyst could reduce the Gibbs free energy barriers and the chiral ligands in the dirhodium catalyst could affect the addition reactions . In 2016, the chemoselectivity of dirhodium-catalyzed [3 + 2] reactions was investigated by Xue’s group and the enantioselectivity of the C–H insertion reaction was investigated by Xie’s group with different DFT methods. In 2017, Wei et al.…”

Theoretical Insight into the Mechansim and Origin of Ligand-Controlled Regioselectivity in Homogenous Gold-Catalyzed Intramolecular Hydroarylation of Alkynes

“…Finally, to quantify different contributions to the regioselectivity, we also performed distortion–interaction analyses − for the four key transition state structures, which was equivalent to the activation strain model. − As shown in Table , the complex 1 B / 1 B ′ can be decomposed into two fragments, 1 B -1 and 1 B -2 / 1 B ′-1 and 1 B ′-2 . According to Table , the two catalyst systems have the similar results in the distortion energies (Δ E dist ), that is, Δ E dist of ortho -cyclization transition states ( TS1 A and TS1 A ′ ) are more favorable than that of para -position cyclization transition states ( TS1 B and TS1 B ′ ), while in the interaction energy (Δ E int ) they are quite the reverse, suggesting that the Δ E int would be responsible for the regioselectivity.…”

Insight into the Mechanism and Regioselectivity of Pd(OAc)2-Catalyzed C–O Bond Activation via a β-O Elimination Approach: A Computational Study

“…Owing to the rapid development of theoretical methods, the computation has become an essential condition to clarify the structure and properties of molecules as well as the reaction mechanism. In particular, the density functional theory (DFT) calculations have been proved to be a valuable tool in the exploration of the reaction mechanism from the microscopic molecular and atomic levels. − In prior years, there were many computational studies for the typical C–H activation and the formations of C–C and C-heteroatom bonds. − Zhang et al carried out the DFT calculations to elucidate the palladium-catalyzed chemoselective C­(sp 3 )–H and C­(sp 2 )–H activation/amidation reactions of carbamoyl chloride . They found the more favored mechanism of C­(sp 3 )–H bond activation than C­(sp 2 )–H bond activation was due to the higher acidity of the benzylic C­(sp 3 )–H bond in this system.…”