The fidelity of DNA
polymerases (Pols) refers to their ability
to incorporate the correct nucleotide into the growing strand during
DNA synthesis. Each Pol operates with a certain degree of fidelity,
from high (∼10–8; ∼1 error in 108 bases) to low (∼10–1; ∼1
error in 10 bases) values. The mechanistic factors behind these differences
in fidelity are poorly understood. Here, we show that the formation
of the Michaelis–Menten complex is critically affected by the
metal-mediated dynamics of local structural features at the catalytic
center of Pols. We demonstrated this by integrating recent structural
and kinetics data of high-fidelity Pol β and low-fidelity Pol
η with equilibrium molecular dynamics and free-energy simulations
of paired and mispaired reactant complexes of these Pols. We found
that local dynamics at the reaction center determines whether the
nucleophile is optimally aligned to incorporate the correct (dCTP)
or incorrect (dATP) nucleotide opposite a template deoxyguanosine
(dG). In Pol β, local structural distortions at the catalytic
site are visible only in the dG:dATP mispair complex, which energetically
disfavors incorrect nucleotide addition and thus promotes high fidelity.
In contrast, in Pol η we observed a more flexible base pair
shape complementarity at the catalytic site. This allows reactive
configurations of matched and mismatched complexes to be formed with
similar ease, thus explaining the low fidelity of Pol η in line
with the experimental evidence. Comparisons with other Pols suggest
that these local metal-mediated structural dynamics at the reaction
center of the catalytic site are crucial to modulating Pol fidelity.