Complex vibratory patterns in an elephant larynx

Abstract

SUMMARYElephants' low-frequency vocalizations are produced by flow-induced self-sustaining oscillations of laryngeal tissue. To date, little is known in detail about the vibratory phenomena in the elephant larynx. Here, we provide a first descriptive report of the complex oscillatory features found in the excised larynx of a 25year old female African elephant (Loxodonta africana), the largest animal sound generator ever studied experimentally. Sound production was documented with high-speed video, acoustic measurements, air flow and sound pressure level recordings. The anatomy of the larynx was studied with computed tomography (CT) and dissections. Elephant CT vocal anatomy data were further compared with the anatomy of an adult human male. We observed numerous unusual phenomena, not typically reported in human vocal fold vibrations. Phase delays along both the inferior-superior and anterior-posterior (A-P) dimension were commonly observed, as well as transverse travelling wave patterns along the A-P dimension, previously not documented in the literature. Acoustic energy was mainly created during the instant of glottal opening. The vestibular folds, when adducted, participated in tissue vibration, effectively increasing the generated sound pressure level by 12dB. The complexity of the observed phenomena is partly attributed to the distinct laryngeal anatomy of the elephant larynx, which is not simply a large-scale version of its human counterpart. Travelling waves may be facilitated by low fundamental frequencies and increased vocal fold tension. A travelling wave model is proposed, to account for three types of phenomena: A-P travelling waves, 'conventional' standing wave patterns, and irregular vocal fold vibration. Supplementary material available online at

Excised larynx experimentation: history, current developments, and prospects for bioacoustic research

“…Focusing on species that vocalize at these two extremes of the frequency range relevant in the animal realm, researchers found evidence that the production of infrasonic and ultrasonic vocalizations could be explained by the same mechanisms as those used in the human voice. For instance, Herbst and colleagues showed that infrasonic elephant rumbles result from MEAD-generated vocal fold oscillation, and that the infrasonic character of these oscillations is causally linked to the size and three-dimensional movements of these vocal folds (Herbst et al, 2012(Herbst et al, , 2013b. A similar conclusion was drawn regarding the production of ultrasonic vocalizations in rats by using ELE (Johnson et al, 2010) and intratracheal pressure and airflow measurements in anesthetized animals (Riede, 2011).…”

“…To investigate such cases through ELE, special attention should be paid to avoid removing inner laryngeal tissue, in order to identify potential vibrating sources (e.g. Herbst et al (2013b) identified a 1:1 phase-locked vibration of vocal folds and ventricular folds in a elephant larynx). Another study using ELE on two red deer larynges documented increased glottal efficiency for non-regular vocal fold vibration regimes at high subglottal pressures, hypothetically suggesting an energetic advantage in animal vocal communication when converting metabolic to acoustic energy in this species (Herbst, 2014).…”

Sexual selection and the loss of laryngeal air sacs during the evolution of speech

“…Experimental data testing these hypotheses directly on real air sacs are currently lacking. One possible area of research, which is likely to prove fruitful, is ex-vivo investigation of the effects of air sacs on call acoustics in excised larynx experiments (see Titze et al, 2010;Klemuk et al, 2011;Herbst et al, 2012Herbst et al, , 2013Bowling et al, 2017;Garcia et al, 2017). Another exciting area, which would provide data on vocal-fold vibration during natural vocalizations (thus accounting for the 'source' of the sound, and allowing for the 'filter' to be analysed -Fant, 1960;Chiba and Kajiyama, 1941), is invivo electroglottography (Brown and Cannito, 1995;Herbst and Dunn, 2018).…”

Renewable energy technology diffusion: an analysis of photovoltaic-system support schemes in Medellín, Colombia

“…Such relationships between structure and behavior can be analyzed with the phase diagram (also called phase plot, phase space, or structure-behavior diagram) (Sterman, 2000). A phase diagram plots two variables on a two-dimensional graph (Herbst et al, 2013) with independent and dependent variables plotted on the X and Y axes, respectively. Since understanding structurebehavior associations is an important prerequisite for designing policies (Davidsen, 1992), the dynamic relationships were explored between key variables in the model and their policy implications were analyzed.…”