Complementary Role of Public and Private Hospitals for Utilizing Outpatient Services in a Hill District in Nepal

Abstract

Background: In Nepal, the private sector has prominently emerged as a provider of health services in recent years. The objective of this paper is to assess whether public and private hospitals are competing for patients with similar socioeconomic strata, or providing services to different segments of the patient population. Methods: Data were collected prospectively from one public hospital and one private-for-profit hospital, both located in close proximity to one another in Tanahu district. A total of 384 and 389 patients presenting themselves for outpatient services available at the district public hospital and a private hospital, respectively, were systematically selected and interviewed using a survey form. The profiles of the patients were comparatively analyzed, and the reasons for using a particular hospital were assessed. Binary logistic regression was used for multivariate analysis.Results: Compared to the patients using the public hospital, patients at the private hospital were younger, possessed a higher level of education, represented indigenous and disadvantaged ethnic groups, and belonged to business or agricultural occupations. The four prominent reasons for using the private hospital were: positive perception/prior experience, followed by recommendation/word-of-mouth, timely availability of services, and trustworthiness. Among the public hospital patients, the prominent reasons were: low fee for services or having insurance, positive perception/prior experience, and trustworthiness. Conclusions: Public and private hospitals have played a complementary role in serving the health needs of different patient population segments in the study district. Keywords: Nepal; private hospital; public hospital; reasons for use; users profile.

Examining the predictors of healthcare facility choice for outpatient care among older adults in India using Andersen’s revised healthcare utilization framework model

“…Economic wellness promotes affordability and enables older individuals to bear the expenses both in the private and public sectors [26]. A study from Nepal revealed that healthseeking behaviour is strongly associated with financial status [27]. The utilization of private healthcare facilities is higher among the wealthier sections of society, while the utilization of public healthcare facilities is prevalent among both the richest and poorest groups.…”

“…The current paper used the upgraded version of Anderson's behavioral model of healthcare utilization [23,24] to understand the mechanism of healthcare utilization by selecting explanatory variables for outpatient care in the Indian context. Previous research in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) and other countries used the same framework to contextualize the characteristics associated with geriatric healthcare utilization [26][27][28][29]. Previous studies have shown that Anderson's specified factors of healthcare facility choice significantly vary with the geographical region, time, demographics, and culture [14,[16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23].…”