Competitiveness Analysis of Kazakhstan Confectionary Sector Using Financial Discriminant Models

Abstract

Abstract:Measuring competitiveness offers hundreds of analytical options. We have chosen to analyze and compare companies of confectionery sector in Kazakhstan. We opted to use bankruptcy and creditworthiness models and compare competitiveness through the financial situation of main competitors on that market. Companies analyzed comprise of two Ukrainian companies (Konti and Roshen), Russian companies (Nestlé Russian branch serving also Central Asian markets and KDV -Yaskino) and three local corporations Rakhat, Bayan Sulu and Konfety Karagandy. Models used for analysis are Altman z-score model, Taffler z-score model, IN99, IN01, IN05, and creditworthiness model. The IN models were created in the Czech Republic based on companies' data from the 1990s which was the period of higher inflation, small currency an big banking crisis, massive imports, developing competition and infrequent political turmoil. These models have comparably much greater benefits for analyzing companies in Kazakhstan because they are based on hundreds of companies in contrast to tens of companies on which Altman or Taffler based their famous and highly predictive models. We present an analysis of models in 2007 -2016 period based on publicly accessible data. We show the IN models have valuable benefits for comparison compared with other older models and that they can disclose certain events or corporate situations in a clearer way than other Altman or Taffler z-score models and should be used in Kazakhstan and improved to suit better the local market environment. JEL Classification Numbers: G32, G33; DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12955/cbup.v5.916

Effect of Psak 72 Implementation in Property and Real Estate’s Financial Health

“…The Taffler model is also used to predict a company's bankruptcy. The formula model produced by Hajek et al (2017) is as follows: TZ = 0,53 PTCL + 0,13 CATL + 0,18 CLTA + 0,16 STA Description: PTCL = Profit Before Taxes / Current Liabilities CATL = Current Assets / Total Liabilities CLTA = Current Liabilities / Total Assets STA = Sales / Total Assets The conclusions of the Taffler model are as follows: a. If the TZ value is> 0.3, the company is healthy financially.…”

Competitiveness and economic profit analysis of Kazakhstan’s poultry companies

“…Besides the mentioned models, we also analyzed how companies create economic profit (Economic Value Added) using Czech Benchmarking Diagnostic System of Financial Indicators INFA (MPO , 2018). Hájek et al (2017) analyzed the confectionery sector in Kazakhstan during 2007-16, using bankruptcy and creditworthiness indicators including the IN models.…”

Deteksi Kesehatan Keuangan Badan Usaha Milik Negara (BUMN) Menggunakan Financial Discriminant Models

“…Model Altman merupakan model yang paling lazim digunakan untuk mengukur financial distress suatu perusahaan. Beberapa penelitian telah menggunakan altman z score diantaranya (Yuliastry & Wirakusuma, 2014), (Hájek, Zhunissova, Čábelová, & Baidildina, 2017), (Afiqoh & Laila, 2018), dan (Idawati & Pratama, 2019). Beberapa penelitian tersebut juga mengombinasikan beberapa model lain seperti Springate, Zmijewski, dan Grover.…”

“…Peneliti menggunakan model Springate didasarkan pada penelitian yang dilakukan oleh (Edi & Tania, 2018) yang menunjukkan hasil bahwa terdapat model diskriminan yang memiliki R square tinggi dalam memprediksi kondisi keuangan perusahaan, yaitu Springate. Sedangkan untuk pengembangan penelitian, peneliti menambahkan analisa menggunakan Taffler's Model yang didasarkan pada penelitian (Hájek et al, 2017). Penelitian ini diharapkan mampu menjadi acuan terhadap pengambilan keputusan stakeholder dalam melihat kondisi keuangan BUMN di Indonesia.…”