Comparison of Visual and Multispectral Radiometric Disease Evaluations of Cercospora Leaf Spot of Sugar Beet

Abstract

Visual assessments of disease severity are currently the industry standard for quantification of the necrosis caused by Cercospora beticola on sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) leaves. We compared the precision, reproducibility, and sensitivity of a multispectral radiometer to visual disease assessments. Individual wavebands from the radiometer, as well as vegetative indices calculated from the individual wavebands, were compared with visual disease estimates from two raters at each of two research sites. Visual assessments and radiometric measurements were partially repeated immediately after the first assessment at each site. Precision, as measured by reduced coefficients of variation, was improved for all vegetative indices and individual waveband radiometric measures compared with visual assessments. Visual assessments, near-infrared singlewaveband reflectance values, and four of the six vegetative indices had high treatment F values, suggesting greater sensitivity at discriminating disease severity levels. Reproducibility, as measured by a test-retest method, was high for visual assessments, single-waveband reflectance at 810 nm, and several of the vegetative indices. The use of radiometric methods has the potential to increase the precision of assessments of Cercospora leaf spot foliar symptoms of sugar beet while eliminating potential bias. We recommend this method be used in conjunction with visual disease assessments to improve precision of assessments and guard against potential bias in evaluations.

Use of a Multispectral Radiometer for Noninvasive Assessments of Foliar Disease Caused by Ray Blight in Pyrethrum

“…As noted by Steddom et al (45) and, earlier, by Nutter et al (32), radiometric data has the additional advantage of being free of rater bias when compared with visual disease assessments. This is especially important in trials where the goal is to determine how candidate fungicides or fungicide programs rank in terms of disease control (i.e., achieving the level of crop health necessary to cost-effectively achieve attainable yields; 30).…”

Diseases of Pyrethrum in Tasmania: Challenges and Prospects for Management

“…The multispectral radiometer helped minimize damage associated with visual disease intensity assessments, and reduced rater bias associated with destructive sampling. Similar to other diseases (49,52,79,88), reflectance within the nearinfrared range (830 nm) and the difference vegetative index (DVI) provided the most accurate, precise, and reproducible estimates of disease intensity (66), as well as yield components such as the dry weight of flowers and pyrethrin yield (65).…”

Quantifying the Severity of Phytophthora Root Rot Disease in Avocado Trees Using Image Analysis

“…The results of any assessment will vary according to an individual's experience. Furthermore, Mahlein [8] argues that the decision can be affected by temporal variation, as well as those incurred from different assessors [8][9][10][11]. An objective technique to assess PRR disease severity in tree canopies is highly desirable.…”