Comparison of Visual and Auditory Modalities for Upper-Alpha EEG-Neurofeedback

Abstract

Electroencephalography (EEG) neurofeedback (NF) training has been shown to produce long-lasting effects on the improvement of cognitive function as well as the normalization of aberrant brain activity in disease. However, the impact of the sensory modality used as the NF reinforcement signal on training effectiveness has not been systematically investigated. In this work, an EEG-based NFtraining system was developed targeting the individual upperalpha (UA) band and using either a visual or an auditory reinforcement signal, so as to compare the effects of the two sensory modalities. Sixteen healthy volunteers were randomly assigned to the Visual or Auditory group, where a radiusvarying sphere or a volume-varying sound, respectively, reflected the relative amplitude of UA measured at EEG electrode Cz. Each participant underwent a total of four NF sessions, of approximately 40 min each, on consecutive days. Both groups showed significant increases in UA at Cz within sessions, and also across sessions. Effects subsequent to NF training were also found beyond the target frequency UA and scalp location Cz, namely in the lower-alpha and theta bands and in posterior brain regions, respectively. Only small differences were found on the EEG between the Visual and Auditory groups, suggesting that auditory reinforcement signals may be as effective as the more commonly used visual signals. The use of auditory NF may potentiate training protocols conducted under mobile conditions, which are now possible due to the increasing availability of wireless EEG systems.

Leveraging machine learning techniques for student’s attention detection: a review

“…This is because EEG signals are extremely artefact prone, nonstationary, and non-linear. For delivering remarkable outcomes, plenty of trials are required to concentrate on cutting down the period of calibration and effective training approaches [60]. Furthermore, EEG headsets require either liquid or gels on electrodes that are quite uncomfortable for the user.…”

Can electroencephalography-based neurofeedback treat post-traumatic stress disorder? A meta-analysis study

“…Among prevalent neurofeedback modalities, visual and auditory feedback are most extensively utilized across a variety of neurofeedback studies. As of now, de nitive guidelines specifying which modality is superior remain elusive [72,73]. Given the encouraging potential of EEG neurofeedback in treating PTSD, it becomes imperative to ascertain the most effective feedback modality to optimize therapeutic outcomes.…”