Comparison of ultrasound elastography, magnetic resonance elastography and finite element model to quantify nonlinear shear modulus

Abstract

Objective. The aim of this study is to validate the estimation of the nonlinear shear modulus ( A ) from the acoustoelasticity theory with two experimental methods, ultrasound (US) elastography and magnetic resonance elastography (MRE), and a finite element method. Approach. Experiments were performed on agar (2%)—gelatin (8%) phantom considered as homogeneous, elastic and isotropic. Two specific setups were built to ensure a uniaxial stress step by step on the phantom, one for US and a nonmagnetic version for MRE. The stress was controlled identically in both imaging techniques, with a water tank placed on the top of the phantom and filled with increasing masses of water during the experiment. In US, the supersonic shear wave elastography was implemented on an ultrafast US device, driving a 6 MHz linear array to measure shear wave speed. In MRE, a gradient-echo sequence was used in which the three spatial directions of a 40 Hz continuous wave displacement generated with an external driver were encoded successively. Numerically, a finite element method was developed to simulate the propagation of the shear wave in a uniaxially stressed soft medium. Main results. Similar shear moduli were estimated at zero stress using experimental methods, μ 0 U S = 12.3 ± 0.3 kPa and μ 0 M R E = 11.5 ± 0.7 kPa. Numerical simulations were set with a shear modulus of 12 kPa and the resulting nonlinear shear modulus was found to be −58.1 ± 0.7 kPa. A very good agreement between the finite element model and the experimental models ( A U S = −58.9 ± 9.9 kPa and A M R E = −52.8 ± 6.5 kPa) was obtained. Significance. These results show the validity of such nonlinear shear modulus measurement quantification in shear wave elastography. This work paves the way to develop nonlinear elastography technique to get a new biomarker for medical diagnosis.